Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream – Extensive Comparison

Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)

 

If you are making a list of the best BB Cream makeup brands, Garnier and Maybelline will definitely make the cut. So join us as we compare the Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream.

This article is meant to serve as a comprehensive guide for the entire line of both products, so we will be very explicit.

 

Table of Contents

Comparison Overview – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

The Garnier is a 5-in-1 BB Cream while Maybelline BB Cream offers 8 benefits. They both hydrate, smoothen, firm, conceal blemish and even out your skin tone.

Garnier BB Cream is available in two formulations: Oily/Combination and Anti-aging. Even with all the developments in the beauty world, few makeup products can boast of the same lasting impact, sun protection and skin-treating benefits as BB Creams.

On the other hand, Maybelline is also available in two variants: Dream Fresh and Dream Pure BB Creams. The major benefit of Dream Fresh is its powerful moisturizing effect while that of Dream Pure is its acne-clearing ability.

Even though they both offer sun protection, Maybelline offers SPF 30 while Garnier has only SPF 15.

Also, they are both oil-free, non-acnegenic and non-comedogenic. Furthermore, they both are both lightweight creams and offer light coverage.

Furthermore, both BB Creams have a creamy texture with mineral pigments to give a natural-looking finish.

They are both suitable for all skin types. However, they have limited shades available for their different lines.

Garnier comes with a fragrance while Maybelline is totally fragrance-free. The former contains parabens while the latter does not.

They both contain antioxidants, Salicylic acids, glycerin and vitamins that would help to nourish your skin cells. The consistency of both creams is runny.

Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)

Buy the Garnier BB cream on Amazon

Buy the Maybelline BB cream on Amazon

 

 

 

Price/Value Ratio – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

Which of the creams adds more value for its price?

Maybelline BB Cream adds more value for its price. Despite the fact it is more affordable than Garnier BB Cream, it has a higher SPF, offers more benefits and has no fragrance. It also contains no paraben, which cannot be said for Garnier cream.

These creams fall in the drugstore category. All in all, they are both considered to be worth the amounts they go for.

 

Comparison Table – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

 

Garnier

Maybelline

SPF 1530
Texture CreamyCreamy
ShadesOily/Combination Skin (3) &Anti-aging (2)Dream Fresh (3)& Dream Pure (3)
Fluid Content 2.5 fl. Oz1 fl. Oz
Skin Suitability All skin typesMost skin types
Fragrance YesNo
Benefits 5-in-18-in-1
Coverage LightLight
Staying Power 24 hoursNot specified
Packaging Plastic squeeze tubeSqueeze tube

 

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

 

Which Situation Is Each Better for? – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

Garnier

Maybelline

In the event you need a cream with anti-aging benefits, this option is your go-to.

This cream is highly recommended for the older people, as it contains age-defying ingredients which give the skin that extra glow that naturally begins to diminish as you age.

Perhaps you need a makeup that will stay put throughout the day without the need for touch-ups, then go grab the Garnier BB Cream.

If you get easily irritated by scented makeup products, then this is for you.

Peradventure you are very concerned about parabens, then this BB Cream would serve you better, as it does not contain any paraben or harmful substance.

Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)
Buy the Garnier BB cream on Amazon Buy the Maybelline BB cream on Amazon

 

Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comprehensive Comparison

Revlon Gel Envy vs Sally Hansen Gel Nail Polishes — In-depth Comparison

Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Face Cream vs Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Face Cream – Which Is Better?

Clinique Moisture Surge Extended Thirst Relief vs Intense Hydrator – Detailed Comparison

Maybelline Fit Me Concealer Light vs Fair – Which Do You Prefer?

Clinique 7-Day Scrub vs Exfoliating Scrub – Extensive Comparison

 

 

 

Video: Which Garnier BB Cream Formula is Best?

If you want to know which Garnier BB Cream formula is best for you, check out this demo and review video…

 

 

Common Features – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

Here are the features both BB creams have in common:

  • Packaging
  • Broad-spectrum sunscreen protection
  • Non-acnegenic properties
  • Presence of hyaluronic acid
  • Skin suitability
  • Non-comedogenic properties
  • Consistency
  • Dermatologically-tested
  • Salicylic acid
  • Finish
  • Antioxidants and vitamins
  • Texture
  • No phthalates
  • Coverage
  • Oil content and moisturizing effect
  • Absorption rate
  • No caking

 

Packaging

To begin with, Garnier and Maybelline BB Creams come in a plastic squeeze tube. Hence, they are very travel-friendly, easy-to-use and sanitary.

Furthermore, they are not susceptible to breakage and globs of the products are not wasted during usage.

 

Broad Spectrum Sunscreen Protection

These BB Creams are both formulated with Titanium Dioxide to offer sun protection. Both lines of Maybelline contain SPF 30. On the other hand, Garnier has SPF 15 for both Dream Fresh and Dream Pure BB Creams.

To learn more about sunscreen protection, check out this article.

 

Non-acnegenic Properties

Both creams are super amazing for acne-prone skin. Due to their oil reduction capabilities, the oil glands in acne-prone areas around the face and neck are shrunk.

Hence, new breakouts of acne are prevented, and blemishes resulting from acne are cleared.

 

Presence of Hyaluronic Acid

Garnier BB cream and Maybelline BB Cream both contain hyaluronic acid. It is a common substance added to cosmetics.

In addition, hyaluronic acid is used to treat very dry and scaly skins. It also reduces the appearance of skin blemishes.

 

Skin Suitability

Which of the creams is more suited to all skin types?

Garnier BB cream is more suited to all skin types than Maybelline BB cream. But Maybelline BB cream is suited for almost all skin types.

 

Non-comedogenic Properties

These two products are non-comedogenic. Therefore, they do not clog the pores of your skin. Furthermore, comedogenic ingredients such as almond oil, beeswax, A & D additives, corn oil, cocoa butter are not present in them.

In fact, skincare experts recommend that you steer clear of comedogenic-rich products because they are known to increase the chances of acne breakouts.

 

Consistency

Garnier BB cream and Maybelline BB Cream both have a runny consistency. But they are not too runny that they cannot afford good coverage.

 

Dermatologically-tested

Garnier and Maybelline BB Creams are both dermatologically-tested. This means they have been thoroughly studied by dermatologists, who in turn, certify that the ingredients used in manufacturing these cosmetics are skin-friendly. Therefore, rest assured that anyone can use them.

 

Salicylic Acid

Salicylic acid is an essential ingredient in food preservatives, cosmetics and medicinal products. But in skincare, it helps to treat acne, dandruff, calluses and warts.

Both creams contain 2% Salicylic acid. This is arguably the largest quantity you can find in any makeup.

 

Finish

In addition to all the above, they both offer a natural shine-free finish. In fact, both creams are not cakey or heavy at all.

 

Antioxidants and Vitamins

These creams contain antioxidants which help to prevent abnormal skin pigmentation. Additionally, they both have vitamin E and C which encourage skin renewal.

 

Texture

The texture of both Garnier BB cream and Maybelline BB cream is creamy.

 

No Phthalates

Phthalates are substances employed in the pharmaceutical, nutritional and cosmetic industry. However, they are widely known to cause birth defects and hormonal dysfunction.

In light of the above, most cosmetic products these days are phthalates-free, including these featured products.

 

Coverage

Both creams help to even out your skin tone and offer light coverage.

Furthermore, on days when you require less coverage than a foundation but more skincare benefits than a tinted moisturizer can offer, opt for any of these BB Creams.

 

Oil Content and Moisturizing Effect

Some types of BB creams are heavy, leading to clogged pores and pimples. Nobody wants this, especially if you have greasy skin and are looking for something that wouldn’t aggravate it.

In light of the above, the Garnier and Maybelline BB Creams are both oil-free. They are formulated with hydrating ingredients to give your skin the healthy glow it desires.

 

Absorption Rate

Both BB Creams have a somewhat normal absorption rate. So there is no need to rush when blending them out.

 

No Caking

Caking is a very common problem with makeup products. In fact, you have struck gold when you finally get one that does not cake. In like manner, the Garnier and Maybelline BB Creams do not cake when worn.

Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)

Buy the Garnier BB cream on Amazon

Buy the Maybelline BB cream on Amazon

 

 

 

Unique Features – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

The following are the features which each BB cream has in a unique manner:

  • Staying power
  • Presence of parabens
  • Fragrance
  • Available shades
  • Anti-aging and anti-wrinkle properties
  • Fluid content

 

Staying Power

Which of the creams has a better-staying power?

Oily/combination and Anti-aging Garnier BB Cream has a better staying power. It can last for up to 24 hours. This means there is absolutely no need for reapplication.

On the other hand, the staying power of Dream Fresh and Dream Pure Maybelline BB Creams were not categorically stated by the manufacturer. However, going by the reviews, they last up to 8 hours.

 

Presence of Parabens

Which of the creams contains parabens?

Garnier BB cream contains parabens in the form of methylparaben, utylparaben and propylparaben. This raises a red flag. So we advise you to use it with caution. On the other hand, Maybelline does not contain parabens.

 

Fragrance

Which of the creams has fragrance?

GarnierBB cream has a fragrance which some persons found to be refreshing while others found it off-putting.

On the other hand, Maybelline is completely fragrance-free. This is particularly great for those who are allergic to scented makeup.

 

Available Shades

Which of the creams has more available shades?

Maybelline BB cream has more available shades than Garnier BB cream. The former has 6 shades: Dream Fresh and Dream Pure have 3 shades each.

On the other hand, Garnier BB cream oily/combination skin has 3 while anti-aging has 2.

 

Anti-aging and Anti-Wrinkle Properties

Which of the creams has anti-aging and anti-wrinkle properties?

Garnier Anti-aging BB Cream has these properties. It contains Pro-Xylene which helps to fight against signs of aging, wrinkles and fine lines. However, this is not a property you would find in the Maybelline BB Creams.

Check out this article to know more about anti-aging creams.

 

Fluid Content

Which of the creams has more fluid content?

Both lines of Garnier BB Creams boast of about 2.5 fluid ounces of the products. On the other hand, Maybelline Dream Fresh and Dream Pure BB Creams each has a fluid ounce content.

Hence, everything being equal, the Garnier BB Cream will serve you longer than the Maybelline.

 

Unique Pros – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

 

Pros Unique to the Garnier BB Creams

i. Longer staying power.

ii. Larger fluid content.

iii. Also contain anti-aging and anti-wrinkle ingredients.

 

Pros Unique to the Maybelline BB Creams

i. No fragrance.

ii. No paraben.

iii. Also offers 8-in-1 benefits.

iv. Higher sun protection.

 

 

 

Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)

Buy the Garnier BB cream on Amazon

Buy the Maybelline BB cream on Amazon

 

 

Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3 — Which Should You Buy?

Olay Total Effects 7-in-1 Moisturizer vs L’Oréal Revitalift Triple Power Intensive Moisturizer – Detailed Comparison

Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations – Which to Go for?

Clinique Moisture Surge Intense Hydrator vs Dramatically Different Moisturizing Gel – Extensive Comparison

Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory – Which Should You Go for?

 

 

 

Video: Trying Out the Maybelline BB Creams

This video shows how effective the Dream Fresh and Dream Pure lines of Maybelline BB Creams can be. Check it out…

 

 

Unique Cons – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

 

Cons Unique to the Garnier BB Creams

i. It is scented makeup.

ii. Also contain parabens.

iii. Lesser sun protection.

 

Cons Unique to the Maybelline BB Creams

i. Shorter staying power.

ii. Lesser fluid content.

iii. Also, no anti-aging formula.

 

Common Pros – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

 

Garnier

Maybelline

Absorption Rate It is absorbed into the skin at a normal rate.In like manner, most of it is absorbed into the skin at a normal rate.
Consistency Even though it has a runny consistency, it won’t bulge.Similarly, the Maybelline BB Cream has a runny consistency.
Sun protection Also, the Garnier BB Cream is formulated with Titanium Dioxide to protect the skin from sunburn and UV rays.Likewise, this option contains sun protection ingredients.
Affordable You get value for every penny spent on this cream.Similarly, this product is also very affordable.
Texture and Pigmentation Also, its creamy texture is fortified with mineral pigments.In like manner, Maybelline is richly pigmented and cream in texture.
Dermatologically-tested The Garnier BB Cream has the approval of skincare experts.Similarly, this option is dermatologically-tested.
Non-comedogenic Also, it does not contain comedogenic ingredients.In like manner, Maybelline BB Cream is non-comedogenic.
Vitamins and Antioxidants The Garnier BB Cream contains several vitamins and antioxidants needed to nourish your skin cells.Similarly, this product contains vitamins and antioxidants.
Packaging It comes in a plastic squeeze tube packaging, which makes it very travel-friendly and easy-to-use.Likewise, this product is well-packaged.
Finish Also, it gives a natural-looking finish.In like manner, Maybelline also gives a natural-looking finish.
Oil-free It is completely void of oil or pore-clogging ingredients.Similarly, this product is totally oil-free.
Hyaluronic acid Finally, the Garnier BB Cream contains hyaluronic acid for the treatment of skin blemishes.Likewise, the Maybelline BB Cream contains hyaluronic acid.
Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)

Buy the Garnier BB cream on Amazon

Buy the Maybelline BB cream on Amazon

 

 

 

Common Cons –Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

 

Garnier

Maybelline

Limited shades The total shade options available for both lines of Garnier BB Cream is 5.Similarly, this option is also very limited in shade variety.
Ophthalmologist caution Also, eye experts warn that the Garnier BB Cream should not be brought in contact with the eyes.Likewise, the Maybelline BB Cream is not safe for the eyes.

 

General Opinion about Both Products – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

Garnier

Maybelline

Firstly, both formulations of the Garnier BB Cream are considered to be great products. Many customers commended the multi-purpose nature of the cream.

Furthermore, many users seem to be attracted to it because of the price. They even acknowledged it was worth every penny.

Additionally, in a consumer’s survey, over 94% of the users agreed they noticed a better glowing appearance after a single-use.

Also, about 90% of the customers affirmed it gave them smoother skin.

However, the fragrance and paraben-rich ingredients repelled some users.

On the other hand, many users were head over heels because of the cream’s 8-in-1 benefits.

Moreover, it is not surprising that many customers considered it a worthy alternative to other expensive creams. The quality makes it worth every penny it goes for.

Furthermore, the fragrance-free formulation makes it good for those with sensitive nostrils.

However, complaints were centred on the fluid content. Many users would love it more if it is bigger.

 

Our Verdict – Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream

Garnier

Maybelline

Firstly, we like that it is formulated with anti-aging and anti-wrinkle ingredients. This makes it suitable for the elderly.

Additionally, the packaging and user-friendliness make it very terrific.

However, the presence of parabens and fragrance raises a red flag. We would love it if these concerns are addressed.

On the other hand, we love the numerous benefits that come with using this cream. Plus, it is very affordable.

Additionally, we like the fact that just about anyone can wear this cream.

However, we will like it more if the fluid content is increased.

 

Garnier SkinActive BB Cream Anti-Aging Face Moisturizer, Light/Medium, 2.5 OunceMaybelline Dream Fresh BB Cream, Light/Medium, 1 Ounce (Packaging May Vary)

Buy the Garnier BB cream on Amazon

Buy the Maybelline BB cream on Amazon

 

Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream – Frequently Asked Questions

 

Is Maybelline BB Cream Good?

Maybelline BB cream is good. It serves the purpose it is meant for, satisfying any user. BB cream is dewy, giving the skin aluminous glow that is not shimmery or overboard. The cream is also light on the face, leaving no room for cakiness.

The cream’s coverage is sheer to light, perfect for those who tend to wear light makeup. Above all, it does not irritate the skin. This means that it leaves up to its non-comedogenic and non-acnegenic claims.

If you are more of a light makeup wearer or you don’t want to use a foundation, you can opt for this BB cream.

 

Should I Use BB Cream Or CC Cream?

Using either BB cream or CC cream will depend on the occasion and what you want to cover. BB cream is usually lighter than CC cream. So if you tend to wear foundation or concealer, you will do better with a CC cream. That is, it will serve you better on days you would rather not use a foundation.

But if you are going for sheer and truly natural, BB cream will go better for you. It is much better for an ‘I just woke up like this’ look. However, if you have blemishes you want to cover without using a foundation or a concealer, use a CC cream.

 

Should I Use a Moisturizer Before a BB Cream?

You can use a moisturizer before using a BB cream, even though some BB creams moisturize the skin. However, using a moisturizer before any skincare product is essential. This is true even when the product contains moisturizing properties and especially if you tend to have dry skin.

This is because a moisturizer will keep your skin from drying out and causing the product to cake or settle into lines. It will also keep the product from drying up the moisture your skin already has. Besides, it will provide a good base for any skincare product to go on. Moisturized skin tends to be softer and smoother.

 

Can I Use Just BB Cream?

You can use just BB cream. It is capable to stand without the need for other concealing makeup products. Even though it is light, it has the ability to cover minor blemishes and imperfections on the skin. This is because it has a slight tint that conceals yet leaves the skin looking natural.

Nevertheless, BB cream serves as a superb base for concealer or foundation. It makes the application of other makeup products easy and smooth. So it is a win both ways: whether you choose to use it alone or as a base for your foundation.

 

What Is DD Cream?

DD cream is daily defense or dynamic do-all cream. It is practically a combination of CC cream and BB cream. This is because it combines the color correcting features of CC cream and the protecting abilities of BB cream.

It usually contains more sunscreen protection factor than a typical BB cream. Plus, it moisturizes, keeps moisture from escaping and has anti-aging benefits.

While it suits all ages, it is great for older people or mature skin. This is due to its anti-aging benefits.

 

Do You Apply Moisturizer Before CC Cream?

The choice of whether to apply a moisturizer before applying a CC cream is up to you. CC cream is already a moisturizer, meaning it has moisturizing properties. So it is not necessary to use a moisturizer with it because it will not deplete the moisture in your skin. instead, it will protect it.

But you cannot go wrong with a good moisturizer, especially if you tend to have dry skin. While it is not necessary, therefore, you can still use a little of your moisturizer before applying a CC cream. It will boost the effectiveness of the moisturizing properties of the cream.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Leave a Comment