 |
 |
For a while now, it has been goodbye to relying solely on the sun to get a tan. Presently, there exists a wide variety of tanning products. In this article, we are comparing two such products. We have Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers, well-known tanning moisturizers.
Before diving straight into the comparison, we see the need to highlight what sunless tanners are. This we consider necessary, in order for you to judge these products correctly.
Table of Contents
What Are Sunless Tanners?
Sunless tanners are products that mimic UV tanning without any form of contact with the sun. They are often a preferred choice because of their many advantages. For instance, they don’t put users at direct risk of skin cancer or sunburn.
Still, sun protection is necessary as there is little guarantee that a sunless tanner will contain SPF. In fact, when it does, it’s hardly enough.
Other names for these products include self-tanners or fake tanners.
Types of Sunless Tanners
The following are among the popular types of sunless tanners:
- Tanning mousses
- Tanning sprays
- Tanning towelettes
- Tanning moisturizers
Let us explain each one in details.
Tanning Mousses
These are generally light in texture but have less moisture than tanning lotions. They are effective for last-minute tanning because they dry speedily. Nevertheless, they are better left in the hands of careful and seasoned users.
Tanning Sprays
Another quick-drying self-tanner is the tanning spray. It does not dry as fast as the tanning mousse but it’s usually ahead of lotions. It is well suited for tanning a lot of skin at once. Sadly, some contain majorly harmful ingredients like mercury.
Tanning Towelettes
These tanning products are extremely easy to use. Their usage sums up to a few swipes. And it can basically be used in private or public. Additionally, they have low chances of being over-applied. In reality, they can’t be over-applied because they are way too faint.
Tanning Moisturizers
Tanning Moisturizers are used daily or frequently just like regular moisturizers. In this case, they gently darken the skin within a short period. They are known for achieving basic glow at the same time, hydrating the skin.
Their drying time mostly depends on the brand but it’s usually 30 minutes or less. These tanners are certainly good choices for first-timers. To learn more about the properties of self tanners, check out this article.
Comparison Overview – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
As has been previously stated, Jergens Natural Glow and L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers have one attribute alike. Both are tanning moisturizers.
But there’s more in common between these products. For example, they both need continued use to build color.
What clearly differentiates them is the smell of Jergens Natural Glow from that of L’Oreal Sublime Glow. The Natural Glow does more than add fragrance to eliminate the smell of tanning.
Asides this, the L’Oreal Sublime Glow tans more than the Jergens Natural Glow. This suggests that the Sublime Glow, for the most part, will fade slower than the Natural Glow.
Furthermore, the Jergens Natural Glow dries off easily unlike the L’Oreal Sublime Glow. That being said, the Natural Glow is far more time-saving.
The L’Oreal Sublime Glow is a glittery moisturizer. Therefore, it is questionable if it’s the right pick for older persons. Conversely, the Jergens Natural Glow will appeal to them so much more.
As we proceed, we will discuss each merit and demerit at length.
|
|
Price/Value Ratio – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Which of the tanning moisturizers offers more value for money?
L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow offers more value for money. For one, it lasts all day. There is no need for reapplication during the day. Two, one application leaves a noticable tan. And it is tested by dermatologists. All these cannot be said for Jergens Natural Glow.
However, do note that L’Oreal Sublime Glow has a scent while Jergens Natural Glow has no scent. This is a downside to using the Sublime Glow.
One aspect that largely satisfies customers when purchasing L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow is the price. For many customers, it delivers a nice tan with a really budget-friendly price tag. Of course, it is highly rated in value for its price.
Now, Jergens Natural Glow is similarly low-cost. But its light tan is not sufficient for everyone. So, some users don’t exactly find it cost-effective.
Comparison Table – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Jergens Natural Glow |
L’Oreal Sublime Glow |
|
| Package | Tube, Bottle | Tube |
| Size | 7.5oz, 10oz | 8oz |
| Color | White | Cream |
| Other Products from Range | Jergens Natural Glow +Firming; 3 Days to Glow; +Nourish and; Face Daily Moisturizer | L’Oreal Sunless Sublime Glow |
| Format | Lotion | Lotion |
| Skin Tone | Fair to Medium, Medium to Tan | Fair, Medium |
Video: Two Tanners, One Face
These brands have both made a name for themselves in the tanning business. But when they’re literally placed side by side, which outperforms the other?
This video below gives you a clear idea…
Which Is Better under What Circumstance? – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Jergens Natural Glow |
L’Oreal Sublime Glow |
| If you prefer a really subtle tan, this tanning moisturizer will most likely please you. Likewise, if you are picky at how much your skin tans, this is a good pick. | This product is great for those who want an obvious but decent tan. It is also for individuals that need fast results since first use, as a rule, produces visible color. |
| To see this product at its finest, exfoliate the skin especially elbows and knees. Shortly after a bath will also do. | If you sweat a lot, this product might be a poor choice for you. Only if you care to reapply each time you perspire. This is because it leaves the tanned skin spotty when it gets partially wet. |
| Due to the fact that this moisturizer is on the thick side, it’s best to avoid use on the face. | The glittery tan of the L’Oreal Sublime Glow is not always appealing. It is more likely to suit the younger populace. |
|
|
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
Maybelline Baby Skin Instant Pore Eraser vs Benefit Porefessional Primers – Extensive Comparison
Common Features – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
The following are similar properties between both tanning moisturizers:
- Moisturizing properties
- Package
- Fragrance
- Gradual effect
- Self-tan
- Thickness
Moisturizing Properties
Everyone’s skin requires moisture regardless of type or tone. That being said, a moisturized skin, amidst other things, tans easily and more evenly. So a sunless tanner that locks in moisture is a gem.
The L’Oreal Sublime Glow is an endowed moisturizer. It holds ingredients such as mango butter, soybean oil and vitamin E that hydrate the skin. Jergens Natural Glow also contains vitamin E as well as assorted oils; olive, jojoba and avocado.
These products are great for tanning dry skin.
Package
As much as packaging is important for protecting the contents of a product, it must be user-friendly. Each use between opening and closing should be easy.
Jergens Natural Glow comes in two containers; a tube and bottle. The L’Oreal Sublime Glow comes in a tube, too. The tubes they have in common are particularly easy to use.
Fragrance
Which of the tanning moisturizers has a more noticeable fragrance?
L’Oreal Sublime Glow moisturizer has a more noticeable scent than Jergens Natural Glow. This is because Jergens Natural Glow suppreses the nasal receptors so the fragrance in it is not easily noticeable or overpowering.
The Natural Glow and Sublime Glow are not fragrance-free. The cause of this smell is the reaction of dihydroxyacetone (DHA) in both products whenever they form a tan. And this is no news to users of tanning products as many of the sunless tanning products have such a heavy smell.
In order to manage this, brands tend to camouflage the smell by including fragrances as in the L’Oreal Sublime Glow. Another way is using odor nullifying technology like the Jergens Natural Glow makes uses of.
Gradual Effect
Tanning moisturizers are chiefly designed for every day or, at least, regular use. With continuous use, the tan darkens. It is also for the purpose of maintaining the tan.
The Jergens Natural Glow and the L’Oreal Sublime Glow generally deliver their darkest tan within 3 days.
Self-tan
A self-tan first and foremost is safer than a suntan. Secondly, it is convenient. It can be done at home instead and it is a cheaper alternative to tanning salons. These products are tanning options that neither sunburn nor cause photo-aging.
Thickness
Jergens Natural Glow and L’Oreal Sublime Glow take a couple of minutes before they are fully absorbed into the skin. In other words, they are quite thick products. This is mainly because of their moisturizing ability.
In the case of the Jergens Natural Glow, it needs about 10 minutes for the gummy feel to vanish. But the L’Oreal Sublime Glow may take up to half an hour.
|
|
Unique Features – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
What is unique about each tanning moisturizer?
One, Jergens Natural Glow has no significant fragrance or scent to it. But L’Oreal Sublime Glow has a significant fragrance.
Two, Jergens Natural Glow does not glisten nor have any shimmer. But L’Oreal Sublime Glow glistens. It makes the skin shine when applied, drawing attention.
Three, it takes about ten minutes for Jergens Natural Glow to get absorbed fully into the skin. However, it takes about twenty to thirty minutes before L’Oreal Sublime Glow to get absorbed into the skin.
The most prominent ingredient in self-tanners is dihydroxyacetone (DHA). It is not only responsible for producing a tan, but it also results in the smell common with these products.
However, the Jergens Natural Glow works with an anti-odor technology that represses nasal receptors. As a result, the smell of the Jergens Natural Glow is slight and distinct.
Then the L’Oreal Sublime Glow surprisingly glistens. Therefore, it draws more attention than the Jergens Natural Glow.
Unique Pros – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Unique Pros of the Jergens Natural Glow
i. It dries faster than the L’Oreal Sublime Glow.
ii. Does not have the typical smell of tanners.
Unique Pros of the L’Oreal Sublime Glow
i. It is generally noticeable after a single use.
ii. All things being equal, it lasts longer than the Jergens Natural Glow.
iii. Moreover, it is dermatologist-tested.
|
|
Unique Cons – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Unique Cons of the Jergens Natural Glow
i. It usually comes out uneven, particularly around the elbows and knees.
ii. The tan would mostly not outlive a day. To maintain it, it certainly needs to be reapplied every day.
iii. The bottle version is not really user-friendly.
Unique Cons of the L’Oreal Sublime Glow
i. It is shimmery without a doubt.
Ii. Furthermore, it’s sometimes too dark for medium skin tones.
Video: Award-winning Self-tanner
What does the Jergens Natural Glow specifically bring to the table? Firstly, it actually lives up to its name – natural glow. In addition, it is comfortable to wear.
See a clear assessment in this video…
Common Pros – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Jergens Natural Glow |
L’Oreal Sublime Glow |
|
| Moisture | With vitamin and oils, this tanning product altogether works as a good moisturizer. | Likewise, it moisturizes the skin. |
| Sunless | This will undeniably prevent unneeded exposure to harmful UV Rays. | The same applies to the L’Oreal Sublime Glow. |
| Affordable | The Jergens Natural Glow is pocket friendly. | It is equally affordable. |
| Color | It basically does a good job of producing a moderate tan. | Similarly, this product tans nicely. |
| Tube | The tube of this product is rather easy to handle. | It also has a functional tube. |
| Skin Suitability
|
The Natural Glow is for all skin tones, though, favours dry skin more. | Same as the Jergens Natural Glow. |
|
|
Video: A Review of the L’Oreal Sublime Glow
A drugstore product with a pretty impressive tan. Interestingly, it doesn’t do so without leaving the skin moisturized. But what about the texture? And the smell?
This video certainly covers all…
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
Maybelline Age Rewind Concealer Neutralizer vs Light – Extensive Comparison
L’Oréal Infallible Pro-Matte Foundation 103 vs 104 – Detailed Comparison
Maybelline New York Dream Mousse Foundation Smooth vs Matte – Which Should You Go for?
Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Regenerating Cream vs Serum—Detailed Comparison
MAC Pro Longwear vs Studio Fix Fluid Foundations – In-depth Review
Common Cons – Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
|
|
Jergens Natural Glow |
L’Oreal Sublime Glow |
|
Smell
Sticky
Chemicals |
Although it improves the sunless tan smell, it’s not odorless.
After drying, it feels sticky for a short while.
It is not paraben, common preservative or fragrance-free.
|
The L’Oreal Sublime Glow has an especially strong smell.
Even when dry, it doesn’t exactly feel so.
It not only contains fragrance but also paraben. |
Users’ Feeling about Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers
Jergens Natural GlowSeveral customers appreciate the Jergens Natural Glow for its subtle colour and delicate glow. Therefore, easily agree that it offers good value for a drugstore product. But when they don’t, they call it a costly moisturizer. This is because these users find the tan far too faint especially the fair to medium version. Another complaint was how poorly the Jergens Natural Glow blends on the joints, that is, elbows and knees. Concerning the smell, users are divided. While some complain bitterly, others find it liberating from the popular sunless tan smell. |
L’Oreal Sublime GlowAlthough it works for both fair and medium skin tones, users recommend it more often for fair skin. Users are also of the opinion that it comes out natural even if it’s heavily applied. Nevertheless, there are a series of complaints about the smell. Additionally, users experience uneven tan whenever the L’Oreal Sublime Glow comes in contact with moisture, for instance, sweat. On the bright side, they approve of the price immensely. |
Our Take on Both Products
We think the Jergens Natural Glow is an easy way to achieve a sunless tan. Its tan may be rather light, unlike the L’Oreal Sublime Glow, but it also brings about glowing skin. Besides, it is a well-priced product.
On the other hand, the L’Oreal Sublime Glow can learn a thing or two from the Jergens Natural Glow to smell better.
In their dual capacity, as moisturizers and tanners, we recommend giving both products a try.
|
|
Jergens Natural Glow vs L’Oreal Paris Sublime Glow Moisturizers – Frequently Asked Questions
Does Jergens Natural Glow Actually Work?
Jergens Natural Glow Moisturizer does work. It is a self-tanning moisturizer you can use in the place of going under the sun to get a tan. The tanning moisturizer gives you a tan and the longer you use it, the deeper the tan becomes. After using it a few times, people begin to notice the change in your skin.
However, tanning moisturizer can get streaky. This is especially true if you get too much of the liquid product on your hands. And if you sweat a lot, it tends to show streaks. Plus, the tanning moisturizer gives an orange hue if there is a lot of it on your hands.
How Long After Jergens Natural Glow Can You Shower?
You will have to wait for at least 4 hours after using Jergens Natural Glow tanning moisturizer before you can take a shower. That is the least time it takes for the tanner to set. This will deliver the best results for you. Anything less than 4 hours will reduce the look of the tan and give less than the best results.
In addition to the above, it takes at least 3 days for the first signs of a tan to begin to show when you use Jergens Natural Glow. This number of days is not a general application to all self-tanners.
How Do You Wash Off Self Tanner?
You wash off a self-tanner by rinsing it off. It is best to go under a shower and let the water run over your body while you lightly lather. Remember that this must be after you have worn the tanner for not less than 3 hours. This will give the product time to set into the skin.
After the shower, pat your skin dry. Do not scrub or rub your skin so that you don’t clean off the tan. Rubbing your skin hard will affect the tan you are getting from the product. This is especially true if you are just starting the self-tanning journey.
Can You Shave After Using Jergens Natural Glow?
You can shave after using Jergens Natural Glow but not immediately after that. This is not peculiar to this self-tanner but is a general rule for all self-tanners. It is best to shave just before you apply any self-tanner, Jergens Natural Glow included. This is because shaving will strip the color of the tan away.
The same is true for waxing. The greater risk with waxing and using a self tanner, however, is that you stand a greater chance of getting irritated skin. If you wax and use a self-tanner, your skin will burn and itch. So it is best to wait a few days after waxing before you use any self-tanner.
Are Self Tanners Bad for Your Skin?
Self-tanners are not bad for your skin. Most self-tanners contain a special ingredient, dihydroxyacetone (DHA) which is responsible for the browning effect of self-tanners on the skin. But the ingredient only affects the topmost skin layer, which is made up of skin cells that are dead.
This ingredient is not harmful in any way, as it does not go beyond the top of the skin. In other words, it does not seep into the skin to cause any adverse reaction.
However, moderation is key. Keep the use of self-tanners to a moderate level. Once you get the tan you want, give your skin some time to adjust before using any again.
Can You Leave Self Tanner On Overnight?
It is alright to leave your self-tanner on your skin through the night. It will not adversely affect your skin as most self-tanners are light and not necessarily loaded down with chemical ingredients.
But go for a tanning mousse instead of any other type of self-tanner. This is because a tanning mousse is usually very light and does not contain an overdose of color. So it tends to dry quickly and does not stain clothing and bedding so much.
