L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comprehensive Comparison

Unless you’re new to the beauty industry, you are bound to have, at least, heard of L’Oreal. Well today, this article will be comparing two products from this amazing cosmetics’ producer that has made a name for itself. Introducing the L’Oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black.

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

 

These two products are part of the L’Oreal lash paradise mascara collection.  Also part of this range is the L’Oreal lash paradise black and black brown. “Take your lashes to paradise” is the catchphrase for this mascara range as found on the brand’s website. The lash paradise collection simply makes your lashes feel that like they’re in heaven (That’s if one exists for lashes).

The L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black really tend to look pretty much the same. That’s why one common question most intending buyers ask when these two products are mentioned is: ‘What really is the difference between them?’

Well, that’s why we are here; to answer that question and any other that you might have had. After placing these two products side by side and comparing them comprehensively, we trust you’ll be able to differentiate them. Also, we hope to help you make the decision on which of these you’ll spend your money on.

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comparison Overview

Let us take a look at a brief summary of the two products. The L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs the blackest black are amazing mascaras with amazing results that are labeled under L’Oreal’s voluminous brand. The voluminous brand was designed to give your lashes a more voluminous look; making them look longer and fuller.

Looking closely at the L’Oreal Lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black, you may just decide that they are the same. And they may well be in the eyes of many.

Two Differences…

However, there are two important differences which are noteworthy. The first is the color. There is a difference, albeit slight, in the shades of black of the two mascaras.

The mystic black is the darkest shade of black available. Ever so slightly, the blackest black is lighter than the mystic black. Would that make a difference? It depends on who is using it.

The mystic black unlike the blackest black comes only as washable mascara. The blackest black on the other hand is available as washable mascara as well as waterproof mascara.

The second major difference is the formula, so to speak. The mystic black, a newer product than the blackest black, comes in a washable formula. There is a slight chance that it is available in waterproof, even though it is unlikely. But the blackest black is available in both the washable and waterproof formulas.

 

 

Superb Mascaras…

In all though, the two mascaras are superb to use. They give length, strength and visibility to any type of lashes, short or long, few or full.

In this comparison article, we aim to show you in details, what makes each bottle of mascara from L’Oreal what it is. We aim to draw your attention to details or features which would give you the information needed to make a great choice. That is to say, knowing how much mascara matters to the everyday woman, young or old, we understand the importance of this article.

Go on this journey with us as we find out the strengths and weaknesses of the L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Price & Value Ratio

The prices of both the L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black are similar. They are low enough to fit into any budget you may have, be it weekly or monthly.

Are they both worth their prices? Well, according to a lot of users, they are well worth the prices. They certainly give value and effect that outweigh their prices. In some cases, users said that they work far better than other mascaras that are sold at almost twice the prices.

The value and satisfaction gotten from using both products is actually quite worth it considering their prices. At ludicrous prices compared to their effectiveness, one might say L’Oreal created these products as a give-away.

There is hardly any user that has been left unsatisfied with the value they got for money spent on either mascara. And that is saying a lot.

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comparison Table

 

Mystic Black
Blackest Black
ModelK2495600K2370000
Color205200, 204
PigmentBlackLighter than the mystic black
Non-Domestic ProductNoSame as mystic black
Brush TypeSoft wavy bristle brushSame as mystic black
SizeFull SizeSame as mystic black
EffectLengthening and volumisingSame as mystic black
Available inWashableWashable and waterproof
Modified ItemNoSame as mystic black
FormulationLiquidSame as mystic black
Dimensions0.8 x 2.8 x 7 inches0.8 x 2.8 x 7 inches
Weight22.7g, 0.05 pounds31.8g, 0.07 pounds
Capacity0.28 fl ozSame as mystic black
Applicator Does not taper outNot specified

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Which is better under What Circumstance?

 

Mystic Black
Blackest Black
You may desire to have a deeper black mascara. If that is so, then the mystic black should work fine for you since it is darker than blackest black.Water should not keep you from looking your best. If you intend getting in contact with water like going swimming or being under the rain, the waterproof blackest black should be your pick.
If you hate being stressed when getting your mascara off, then mystic black is your best bet. It can be easily washed off using just soap and water.The washable blackest black mascara can be easily washed off without much hassle. However, if you applied the waterproof version because you had to ‘dance in the rain’; it won’t just come off.

 

If it is not too much of a bother to spend some extra penny on an eye makeup remover, then you’re good to go. This is because that’s the only way that mascara is coming off darling.

Having just the washable version kind of places a limitation on the mystic black’s versatility. Anyway it’s still fantastic mascara.Since it comes in either washable or waterproof, the blackest black has a slight advantage as it could be used as the occasion demands.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Common Features

L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black look alike. These two products bear so many similarities which makes it somewhat difficult for one to notice any difference. Being made by the same manufacturers, belonging to the same brand and collection makes them share a lot in common. So let’s get to it and discover what these similarities are…

Pigment

This is pretty much obvious from the name of both products. The L’Oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black both come in black pigmentation.

This is the color that is seen as you apply these lovely mascaras to your lashes. Users have confirmed that both products seemingly altered the original color of their lashes and made them look black.

However, the original color of your lashes will determine how many coats you need to apply to achieve that black appearance.

In the L’Oreal lash paradise collection, the other pigment available is the black brown. So if you feel like not going all black, the black brown is an option available.

Even though the mystic black and blackest black are similar in pigmentation, their color tones are different. The mystic black gives you a deeper black than blackest black. While blackest black is a deeper black than the L’Oreal lash paradise black.

Brush Type

Both the L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black mascara have the same brush type. With a soft wavy bristle brush, the content of these amazing mascaras are easily applied to the lashes to achieve that voluminous look.

The wand itself is fixed in nature and cannot be bent and serves as the cover for the product. The wand size is comparatively smaller than other popular mascara products. This sometimes requires precision while applying; brings out the artist in you.

There are other brush types that are bendable, while some possess an elastomer brush. An elastomer brush possesses elastic properties that cause it to return to its original position after the force is removed. The L’Oreal lash paradise mystic black and blackest black brush does not act that way.

The number of bristles on the brush of both products is also the same. According to the description of both products, the bristles are over 200 in number. The number of bristles allows the brush to capture your lashes completely to bring about a packed fringe result.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

Container

The similarity between these two products is even evident in their container design. The L’Oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black mascara both have a metallic cylindrical container. This container houses both the brush and the mascara contents.

The container’s color is also the same pink color with a golden band around the neckline that has “L’Oreal Paris” inscribed on it.

The dimension of these products is also the same. The L’Oreal lash paradise mystic black and blackest black both have a 0.8 x 2.8 x 7 inches dimension. This makes it portable enough to be carried along easily in your purse or little bag.

Ingredients

The fact that these products are labeled (named) differently attests to their difference. And what makes products differ from each other most times is the content; that is the ingredients they contain.

In the case of L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black, they have similar ingredients as well as different ones. The similar ingredients are the major ones while those that are different are basically because of the color tone.

Effects

Effect has to do with the results you get after applying these mascaras. The mystic black and the blackest black mascaras are known for their volumising effects. That means after using either L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black or L’Oreal Lash Paradise blackest black, you get fuller lashes. These products make your lashes appear and look fuller than they actually are.

 

 

 

 

Apart from being able to add volume to your lashes, these mascaras last all day long; amazing right? So it eliminates the need for you to constantly reapply during the day.

Capacity

Both products have the same capacity of 0.28 fl. Oz. This is the maximum content capacity these products can carry. Some online sources list the L’Oreal lash paradise blackest black as 0.25 fl. Oz.; however, this is not so.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – What Is Special to Each Mascara?

Above, we’ve been able to see the striking similarities between these two products that make them look no different. Yet, these mascaras have some few things that set them apart from the other one. Would you like to find out?

Color Tone

The major distinguishing difference between the L’Oreal Lash Paradise mystic black vs blackest black is the color tone. For L’Oreal lash paradise mystic black, the color tone is even darker than blackest black. The given color number for mystic black is 205 while that of blackest black is 204 (waterproof) and 200 (washable).

Mystic black is the one with the darkest color tone in the L’Oreal lash paradise collection. Nevertheless, this is not really an advantage but just a matter of preference. Which would you go for: mystic black or blackest black? 

Waterproof Feature

The L’Oreal lash paradise collection comes in either a washable or waterproof formula. What does this mean? The washable feature means the mascara can easily be washed off using soap and water.

And it will likely smudge and run off when exposed to water, such as rain. (No one loves a smudged mascara look; honestly it’s not a nice sight to behold). The waterproof feature, on the other hand, tends to stand the test of the attack of water. However, it is somewhat difficult to remove without the help of a makeup remover.

In texture, the washable mascara is wet in nature while the waterproof mascara. The dryness of the waterproof mascara keeps the lashes firmly in place even when it is affected by water.

The L’Oreal Lash Paradise blackest black tend to have an advantage in this area over the mystic black mascara. This is due to the fact that the former comes in both a washable and a waterproof feature. It is important to note that this makes the blackest black have 2 products in the lash paradise collection: Whereas, the mystic black only comes as washable mascara.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Unique Pros

We’ve looked at what makes mystic black unique from blackest black. We also need to discuss the pros that are unique to each of these mascaras. 

Pros Unique to L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black

Darkest Black

The mystic black is the darkest shade of black you can find on the lash paradise line of mascaras. It adds a mystery and sophistication to whomever wears it. This is apart from adding volume, length and strength.

Additionally, another good thing about this really dark pigmentation is the fact that it can darken any eye lash color. You see, sometimes we may want to go all smoky-eyed. This mascara will enhance that look and remove any other color you do not want.

Washable

As mainstream as this may be, it is actually a good quality. You see, when you come out from a night out in town or from a long day at work, cleaning your makeup is the last thing on your mind. All you want to do is get some sleep.

This washable quality of the mystic black makes it priceless at such times. You can wipe it off with makeup wipes and get it all off at once. It may run easily but it will not stick when it is not needed to. 

Weight

Not that this matters much or that it could be a deal breaker but the mystic black weighs little or nothing. It is no extra weight in your makeup case, unlike some mascaras that are bulky. It is very portable. This is actually something to consider.

Applicator Size

The mystic black mascara from L’Oreal has an hour-glass-like applicator. Applying mascara with it does not leave smudges on your eye lids nor does it form globs at the tip. If you have ever used mascara with large applicator, you would understand the beauty of this better.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

Pros Unique to L’Oreal Lash Paradise Blackest Black

Color

Lashes are dark for most people. A larger percentage of people on earth have black or dark brown eye lashes. So whether a mascara is black or colorless does not make much difference, right?

It does. It really does. And even though a lot of people would prefer really black mascara, there are those who would not mind having something not so dark.

The pigmentation of the blackest black, contrary to its name, is not as black as the mystic black. But it still serves its purpose in not looking too heavy or clumpy atop the eyes.

 

 

Waterproof and Washable

L’Oreal Lash Paradise blackest black comes in waterproof and washable formulas. Whether you have to be under water or not, there is one just for you.

The waterproof formula is long lasting because it does not wear or run easily. Sweating or swimming do not have any effect on it.

However, if you do not wish to use that in the blackest black, you have the option of the washable formula. Whichever way you choose to go, L’Oreal has got you covered.

Easy to Clean Off

It is easy to be wiped off, whether you choose the washable formula or the waterproof formula. Most people know that waterproof makeup is difficult to remove. So oil-based waterproof makeup removers are usually used.

But in this case of the waterproof formula of the blackest black, makeup or even baby wipes would do. It does not take an army to get it off your lashes.

Causes No Irritation

Nobody deliberately allows mascara get into their eyes but accidents happen. If it does, it would not cause any irritation.

Even when it does not get into the eyes, it still will not cause any adverse reaction. Some people react negatively to mascaras, whether they get into the eye or not. It is smooth and easy.

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Unique Cons

Now, let us take a look at the downsides of each mascara. Nothing is that perfect. There has to be something, right?

Cons Unique to L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black

Adverse Reaction

Not everyone reacts badly to this mascara. But some users have reported having redness of the eyes and severe itching when they use the mystic black. What this means is that some people have the tendency to react in a negative way to the mascara. It could also mean it is not hypoallergenic.

The problem could stem from one or two of the ingredients used. But whatever be the case, it is advisable to read the ingredients to see if there is any you are allergic to.

Possibility of Clumping

There is the slightest chance of the mystic black clumping if it is applied wrongly. The problem with this is that there is no exact way to apply it. What works for one may not work for another.

One of the possible reasons is that the blackness of the mascara adds to its look of fullness. When it is coated more than twice, it stands the chance of getting too thick. Hence, the occurrence of clumping.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

Cons Unique to L’Oreal Lash Paradise Blackest Black

Applicator

The brush with which the mascara is applied does not thin out at the end, which is usual for most mascaras. In fact, the whole brush part is thick, not thin.

For those with very short or thin lashes, this could tend towards a problem. Even though it is soft with many bristles, the thickness of it can be discouraging. It could leave marks on the eye lids that would make your overall look untidy.

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Pros Common to Both

 

 

Mystic Black

Blackest Black

Effect The mystic black adds a certain type of allure and mystery to the eyes. Coupled with the liquid eye liner from L’Oreal, you would get an overall stunning look.

 

Your lashes would gain volume, appear longer and become stronger with time, no matter how scraggly they are.

Similarly, the blackest black gives you the same effect.
Washable With the mystic black, you do not have to go an extra mile to get it off your eyes. It is one of those makeup products that you can get off easily, especially when you are worn out.Likewise, the washable and waterproof types are easy to be wiped of, with warm water together with wipes.
Type of BrushSoft and pliable, the mystic black brush comes with about 200 or more bristles.

These number of bristles ensure that no single lash is left untouched when you run the brush through them. This gives you a perfect, well-tended look.

The same is applicable with the blackest black.
Affordability The mystic black fits so well into any type of budget you may have. There is no need to break the bank to have it, as it is not a high end product. However, this does not detract from its effectiveness.The same is applicable with the blackest black.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Cons Common to Both

 

Mystic Black

Blackest Black

Possibility of ClumpingOver application of the mystic black can cause the mascara to become clumped. The main concern is knowing when to stop coating.The same is applicable with the blackest black.
Size It comes in a 0.28 fl. oz. which means that it is too small. This is common with mascaras. But considering its price, you would think it could be somewhat bigger.The same is applicable with the blackest black.

 

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – People’s Take on Both of Them

 

Mystic Black

Blackest Black

Users love the look of the mystic black on them because it is easy to wear. The very black pigment of it adds to the color of their lashes in a way little else can do.

Those with scanty eye lashes have found that it adds length and volume to the lashes, shading the eyes and brightening them at the same time.

The brush has a way of rolling up the lashes, even the shortest ones, and fluffing them up.

While it is not exorbitantly priced, the little bottle of mascara has raised some brows due to its price. And if they can have something cheaper but with the same results, why ever not?

But some users value the effect so do not mind the price.

The fact that this can be had in both washable and waterproof formulas is an advantage users have found helpful. Added to the fact that the waterproof formula is easy to wash off, they cannot get enough of it.

The waterproof formula can stay on for so long. One user said she wore it to bed and woke up with just a little smudge from it. This feature has endeared it to many.

People also tend to veer towards the blackest black because it is somewhat cheaper than the mystic black. They do not see why the mystic black should cost any more than the blackest black since they both give practically the same effect.

The size and shape of the applicator could be a turn off for them, though. Lots of complaints have come from users about having mascara smudged all over their eye lids due to the inconvenient applicator.

 

 

 

l'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise mystic blackl'oreal lash paradise mystic black vs blackest black -- l'oreal lash paradise blackest black
  Get the mystic black now! Get the blackest black now!

L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Our Take on Both of Them

 

Mystic Black

Blackest Black

Ingredients

This mascara is a great blend of ingredients and finesse. Your lashes get pampered while you look flawless, all from using it.

Also noteworthy is the fact that it comes from a trusted makeup and skincare brand adds to its allure. But the chance that someone would react to it negatively, as has been noted, is something to worry about.

There is also the chance of clumping from using it. And that does not look good on anyone. If there is a way to look into this, that would be great.

Price

In addition to that, the price should also be looked into. It is a given that ingredients make up the pricing of any product. But if people choose to go another way, what is the point?

However, we can say that overall, the mystic black is a reliable mascara, any day, any time.

If you need such a mascara today, get the mystic black here now!

Similarly, the blackest black is a mixture of skin-friendly ingredients, done in a way as to give the best results.
Formulas

Oh, the sweetness of the blackest black. Not only can it be had in the washable formula, it can also be had in the waterproof formula. And we all love waterproof makeup because of their staying power.

Secondly, we all appreciate any waterproof makeup product that can be wiped or washed off easily. This is one of them. Using any wipes, with warm water, you are good to go. Even if you use just wipes, you would still get most of it off. That is gold for every woman. We love that.

Hypoallergenic?

It is difficult for it to cause any irritation to the eyes. Does this mean it is hypoallergenic? It is not specified. But going from what we have seen, it can be trusted to not cause any adverse reaction.

In addition to the fact that it is hard to get clumped, what more can we ask for? This is probably one of the best qualities any mascara can have. If you can successfully wear your mascara without having it flake or clump during the day, you have a winner.

If you have been looking for such a mascara, get the blackest black here now!

Ijeoma Chukwuemelie

I am your girl-next-door but there is nothing normal about me because normal is boring. I read a lot and I have a very active imagination. I like to travel, especially to places with ancient histories. There's so much to see, it's almost unbelievable. There is absolutely no price for awesomeness...or attractiveness, for that matter. And I am both.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Privacy Preference Center

    Necessary

    Advertising

    Analytics

    Other