|
|
|
If you’ve ever searched for top gel eyeliners, we are guessing that you surely came across MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner.
Here, we are comparing them specifically for you. But first, a quick look at eyeliners and their types. We’re positive it will help you measure these two correctly.
Table of Contents
What Are Eyeliners?
Eyeliners are makeup products primarily used to accentuate or enhance the lash line. They can be applied from the inner corners of the eyes past the outer lash line.
When choosing eyeliners, consider six things:
- Eye size
- Shape
- Color
- The preferred style of lining
- Occasion
- How easily it cleans
Types of Eyeliners
The following are among the popular types of eyeliners:
- Liquid eyeliners
- Gel eyeliners
- Pencil eyeliners
- Gel pencil eyeliners
- Shadow eyeliners
Liquid Eyeliners
Liquid eyeliners create fine and precise lines that typically end in a swooping arc. When applied neatly, liquid eyeliners are always striking. But it takes a while to perfect such a method of application.
These kinds of eyeliners largely vary. For example, one might come with an inkstand and another resembling a pen. Additionally, the sizes of their brush and pen tips differ.
They are, to a large extent, great choices for oily lids.
Gel Eyeliners
Eyeliners normally found in pots are known as gel eyeliners. Some brands also include a brush for application. But with diverse brushes, the same eyeliner will come out differently.
Another likeable feature is that they are creamy. And because of this, they create soft lines, one that can be smudged for looks such as a smoky eye.
Nonetheless, as with the liquid eyeliner, it needs a bit of practice to master. Also, it’s likely to dry and the brushes used must be kept clean.
Pencil Eyeliners
Pencil eyeliners have actually been around for a long time. They are excellent for routine makeup and applying closely to the waterline. In addition, smoky eyes are easily achieved with this type of eyeliner. However, a sharpener needs to be kept close by and they may tug on the skin.
Gel Pencil Eyeliners
These fall in between pencil and gel eyeliners. They usually have a creamy texture like the latter, but slim package like a pencil. Gel Pencil liners are rather easy to apply. They are pigmented yet create soft lines. Nevertheless, they won’t create the best pointed or sharp edges.
Shadow Eyeliners
Sometimes eyeshadows are designed to work as eyeliners. This majorly works on two occasions. First, to achieve an effect that needs blending out. Second, working with shaky hands. They obviously cannot create precise curves and tips.
Comparison Overview – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
To begin with, the two products under comparison are the same type of products – gel eyeliners.
MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner can last for several hours a day.
Furthermore, these products have the same texture and finish. They are both creamy, with a matte finish.
As for how they are packaged, this is also similar. The MAC Fluidline and Maybelline Eyestudio eyeliners particularly come in portable pots.
And, perhaps more importantly, these two come tested by ophthalmologists.
Their point of divergence is in a few things. Firstly, animal testing is carried out by Maybelline for the Eyestudio Eyeliner but MAC doesn’t carry out such.
Another difference is that the Fluidline Eyeliner is sold with no brush whereas the Eyestudio Eyeliner has a brush of its own.
Lastly, they differ slightly in pigment intensity. The Eyestudio Eyeliner gives a richer colour in just one stroke.
As we move on, these similarities and differences will be better detailed.
 |
 |
Price/Value Ratio – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
Which of the eyeliners offers more value for money?
Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner offers more value for money. It is noticeably more pigmented when applied than MAC Fluidline Eyeliner. The eyeliner from Maybelline also comes with a brush for application while that from MAC has no brush.
For all the features it has, it is still decently priced, way less expensive than MAC Fluidline eyeliner.
Comparison Table – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
MAC Fluidline Eyeliner |
Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner |
|
| Size | 0.106oz/3g | 0.099oz/2.8g |
| Texture | Creamy | Creamy |
| Finish | Matte | Matte |
| Package | Pot | Pot |
| Range | 14 shades | 4 shades |
| Durability | 10hrs+ | 10hrs+ |
Video: And the Winner Is…?
The similarities of these products could actually make them substitutes for each other. If it’s based on cost, it’s easy to decide. But considering other factors, which is better?
This video will possibly determine which you’ll put your mind to…
Which Is Better under What Circumstance? – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
MAC Fluidline Eyeliner |
Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner |
| Those that undergo a lot of physical activities would surely be pleased with this eyeliner. It lasts through sweating and it won’t clear off as you wipe the sweat away. | Anyone looking for budget-friendly eyeliners would definitely find this product one of the best of its kind. |
| Secondly, this product takes time to completely remove. For those that do not have the patience to thoroughly cleanse their face, this is not your best choice. | Furthermore, this product is for you if you like dark and obvious eyeliners. This is because the pigment is rich. |
| Whether on oily, normal or dry lids, this gel liner is not going to smudge. Hence, a product for everyone, with even 14 versions to choose from. | If you have oily lids you want to use a primer. Or expect it to otherwise last less and maybe smear a little as day passes. |
|
|
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comprehensive Comparison
Revlon Gel Envy vs Sally Hansen Gel Nail Polishes — In-depth Comparison
Clinique Moisture Surge Extended Thirst Relief vs Intense Hydrator – Detailed Comparison
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer Light vs Fair – Which Do You Prefer?
Common Features – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
The following are the features both eyeliners have in common:
- Packaging
- Texture
- Lasting power
- Pigmentation
- Ophthalmologically-tested
- Finish
Let us discuss the features in details.
Packaging
The first contact a buyer has with these products is their black packets. Inside the boxes are little see-through pots with lids that screw-on. Although the lid of the Fluidline Eyeliner is black and plastic, that of the Eyestudio is grey and steel.
Their packages make them easy to carry around.
Texture
The textures of the Fluidline Eyeliner and Eyestudio Eyeliner are creamy. So, they’re easy to apply without pulling too much on the skin. It also makes them flexible enough for a blending out.
Lasting Power
Both Fluidline Eyeliner and Eyestudio Eyeliner last for long periods. One of the reasons is because they are waterproof. Hence, they stay on even with sweat, rain and the likes. Another reason is as a result of their finish.
Pigmentation
Pigmentation basically has to do with the colour of the makeup items. Notwithstanding, products of the same colour can have more pigment than others.
The pigmentation of both Fluidline Eyeliner and Eyestudio Eyeliner is pleasant, although better in the Eyestudio Eyeliner. Also, they both have ranges that offer more than the typical black liner.
Ophthalmologically-tested
Cosmetics products asides their various purposes, should certainly not harm one’s health. In order to prove this, brands have their products tested by experts.
Since Fluidline Eyeliner and Eyestudio Eyeliner are both eye makeup products, the expert best suited to test them is an ophthalmologist. Having done so, these products are now considered safe to use. To know more on risk-free eye products, see this article.
Finish
Matte often means that a product is oil-free or has small quantities of oil. This further implies quick drying and long wearing, as seen in the eyeliners we have here. Ordinarily, their creamy texture should cause smudging. But with a matte finish, they dry quick and stay put.
|
|
Unique Features – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
There are a few features each eyeliner has uniquely and they are:
- Accessories
- Pigment
The details of each feature are discussed below.
Accessory
Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner comes with a brush, unlike MAC Fluidline Eyeliner. The brush is rather sturdy and has different tips at both ends. At one end is a thin brush while the other has a curved foam applicator. The brush easily draws eyeliner closer to the lash line and the foam is certainly better for blending.
Pigment
There’s obviously more pigment available in the Fluidline Eyeliner range. The range overall comprises of blue, green, brown and other shades.
On the other hand, the Eyestudio Eyeliner comprises just three darker shades and one eggplant color. But a single stroke shows intensely compared to the Fluidline Eyeliner.
|
|
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
Clinique Moisture Surge Extended Thirst Relief vs Intense Hydrator – Detailed Comparison
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer Light vs Fair – Which Do You Prefer?
Clinique 7-Day Scrub vs Exfoliating Scrub – Extensive Comparison
Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3 — Which Should You Buy?
Ambi Skincare Fade Cream vs Clinique Even Better Dark Spot Corrector – Extensive Comparison
Video: A Colorful Line of Eyeliners
The Fluidline Eyeliner is basically not joking with variety. Some of the colors in the range play safe, while others definitely don’t. But do they glide on or last equally?
Watch this video to find out…
Unique Pros – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
Which of the Eyeliners Is Smear-proof: MAC Fluidline or Maybelline Eyestudio?
MAC Fluidline is smear-proof, even on oily eyelids. It does not wipe off easily while you are wearing it yet it cleans smoothly. This is partly due to its matte finish.
Which of the Eyeliners Offers More Colors: MAC Fluidline or Maybelline Eyestudio?
MAC Fluidline offers more colors to choose from. It has about 14 colors and not all of them are dark. Some of them are bold colors like green and pink.
Which of the Eyeliners Is Better Pigmented: MAC Fluidline or Maybelline Eyestudio?
Maybelline Eyestudio is better pigmented. With just one stroke, you get a rich color payoff. You don’t even need a second stroke unless you choose to.
Which of the Eyeliners Is Less Expensive: MAC Fluidline or Maybelline Eyestudio?
Maybelline Eyestudio is much less expensive than the MAC Fluidline. But that is no news; MAC products are usually more expensive than others.
Which of the Eyeliners Comes with a Brush: MAC Fluidline or Maybelline Eyestudio?
Maybelline Eyestudio comes with a sturdy brush for easy application. The brush has two ends: one for application and the other for blending.
Unique Cons – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
Unique Cons of the MAC Fluidline Eyeliner
i. Its cost is significantly high.
ii. The absence of a brush is surely disappointing.
iii. The pigment is somewhat less intense than the Eyestudio Eyeliner.
Unique Cons of the Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner
i. Generally, the ability of the brush is limited.
ii. It is also tested on animals. This is obviously a no-no for some.
iii. Lastly, the texture is not as creamy as the Fluidline Eyeliner.
Common Pros – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
MAC Fluidline Eyeliner |
Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner |
|
| Package | The package of the Fluidline Eyeliner is especially light for travel. | This product is also easy to carry. |
| Creamy | Its creaminess makes it rather gentle on the skin. | In the same vein, it has a creamy feel. |
| Finish | The matte finish ensures that it dries easily. | Its finish is also matte. |
| Longwearing | It lasts many hours in general. | The Eyestudio Eyeliner is equally long-wearing. |
| Waterproof | Also, this product is not threatened by moisture. | Similarly, it is a waterproof product. |
| Pigmentation | It has decent pigmentation. | Eyestudio Eyeliner is highly pigmented. |
| Safety Test | In addition, it has been proven safe for human eyes. | Likewise, it has been tested by an ophthalmologist. |
| Fragrance-free | It’s basically a fragrance-free product. | This eyeliner is also scent-free. |
|
|
Video: What’s the Eyestudio Eyeliner indeed like?
This eyeliner undoubtedly does what a gel eyeliner should. Even with cons mentioned in the video below, the Eyestudio eyeliner still scores above average. With it, you can be sure of well-defined eyes.
See for yourself…
Common Con – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
MAC Fluidline Eyeliner |
Maybelline Eyestudio Eyeliner |
|
| Tendency to dry | The lid must always be screwed on properly because the contents could dry. | It should be well covered to prevent it from possibly drying.
|
Users’ Feelings – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
MAC Fluidline EyelinerThis product, according to a lot of users, endures serious workouts, work-filled and hot days. For them, it is undeniably long-lasting. Another common take among customers is how smooth it feels. They also seem to like that it dries quickly, although a few users have to learn to be faster. Most of the bigger complaints particularly come from those with sensitive eyes, especially the morning after it’s not cleaned properly. |
Maybelline Eyestudio EyelinerIts price is significantly well-received among buyers. Additionally, users say good things about the texture. They also find it moderately easy to use and fast in drying. Once it dries, many customers see that it stays put all day. And those that complain of occasional smearing mostly have oily lids. Several customers are of the opinion that brush that follows the product is rather average. That, some looks would certainly not be achieved except with other brushes. |
Our Take – MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner
We honestly think the Fluidline Eyeliner is a great product. It is finely pigmented and it lasts for surprisingly long hours, without smearing. An applicator following it would have far more satisfying, though.
Eyestudio Eyeliner is such a well-priced product, in our opinion. And it even comes with a brush. Considering the long wear too, we certainly recommend, despite it being less gentle.
|
|
MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner – Frequently Asked Questions
Which Eyeliner Is Better: Gel or Liquid?
Gel eyeliner is better than liquid eyeliner.
For one, gel eyeliner is creamy and thick, making the eyes look fuller with just one application. It is also gentler on the eye skin because of its delicate nature and is more forgiving of imperfections. You can easily correct mistakes and build it.
Liquid eyeliner, on the other hand, needs a steadier hand and is not so forgiving on mistakes. It is usually not as thick or creamy as a gel eyeliner. While its application is easier and gives a more defined line, it is not so buildable.
Which Brush Is Best for Gel Eyeliner?
A brush with a fine angle is the best for gel eyeliner. This is because it allows for the easy and fluid movement of the hand while applying the eyeliner. Because gel eyeliners are usually thick, it can be quite a chore if you use the wrong brush.
This type of brush allows you to apply any type of line, thin or thick. Whether you want to create a flick, a tight line or cat eye, it will serve you. Moreover, it is the perfect accessory for anyone new to the gel eyeliner business.
Do You Wet the Brush for Gel Eyeliner?
You don’t wet the brush before applying gel eyeliner. Though the consistency is thick, it is not sticky or gummy as to require wetting the brush before application. Gel is just that: gel. It is easy to apply.
Wetting the brush will make the gel eyeliner not stick to it. And then, applying it will not be possible because it is mixed with water.
Just dip the tip of the brush into the gel eyeliner pot to take enough of the product. Then apply it in a fine line along the lash-lines of your eyelids.
Should I Use Liquid or Pencil Eyeliner?
Using liquid or pencil eyeliners is dependent on the look you want to achieve. But know this; your eyes will pop more if you use liquid eyeliner. It is shinier and more lustrous. It also gives an appearance of fuller lashes to your eyes.
but a pencil eyeliner is easier to apply. It is more user-friendly, especially for beginners and allows room for better strokes. If you are going to use mascara, then you will do better with a pencil eyeliner.
Is Gel Eyeliner Good for Beginners?
Gel eyeliner is good for beginners but not as good as pencil eyeliner. Mistakes are more forgivable with a pencil eyeliner than with gel eyeliner and definitely more so than with liquid eyeliners.
If you have been using eyeliners before now but are new to gel eyeliners, then you have nothing to worry about. But if you are completely new to the whole eyeliner game, you will do well to begin with a pencil. Then you can graduate to gel eyeliner.
Does Gel or Liquid EyeLiner Last Longer?
Gel eyeliner lasts longer, mostly because it is usually more pigmented than liquid eyeliner. The color payoff is greater so it sits on the skin better. Plus it absorbs easily so does not have the chance to smudge.
Liquid eyeliner tends to take a little longer to dry. But it is easier to wipe off and any liquid can cause it to smudge. You will find you have little of it left at the end of the day. However, this is not the case with gel eyeliners.
