MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – A Detailed Comparison

We have affiliate relationships with the providers of the products, goods and services that are linked to on this page and may be compensated when you buy. But do note that it doesn't increase the cost of the products to you in any way or determine our verdict on a product/service.​​​​​​​

If there is one brand you can go to for some of the finest and classy lipsticks, it is MAC. With the speed at which lip trends keep changing, it is a miracle that any brand manages to keep up. But MAC has proven to be up to the task, as shown by the highly coveted duo of MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks.

In other words, MAC is a force to be reckoned with when it comes to lipsticks. Enter any beauty store worth its salt and MAC lipsticks would stare right back at you in their numbers. As high end as they tend to be, people still pick them over many others because they give perfect satisfaction.

Looking at the MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks, you would be tempted to go “Whoa, ok, what is going with Mac? Giving us the same lipstick with different names?” That is, that would be your reaction at first glance.

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

 

Slight Differences…

But a closer look would show you that both lipsticks are not as similar as they appear at first. Yes, there are lots of similarities. However, there are also a few features that set them apart. You would be able to tell which is which.

Going further, this comparison article is going to detail these core differences to help you pick which suits you better. Then we will list the similarities; these similarities will show you why these two matte lipsticks are just right for you.

Perhaps you have been undecided about getting one. Or you already have one and cannot decide if getting the other is necessary. Well, this comparison will help you get there. And boy, would you be glad with your decision to buy MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks.

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Comparison Overview

Just in the event you do not know it for sure yet, then know that MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy both have matte finish. So if you are looking for a lipstick with a creamy or satin finish, these are not for you.

As we have mentioned before, both come in almost the same shade. There is a difference, almost imperceptible to the average eye. If there is a chance you are not a connoisseur of lipsticks, it would go right over your head.

Firstly, honeylove is a light shade of beige with a light rose color undertone. It sits pretty between warm and cool, nothing too loud about it. It can go with any outfit and for any event. And it is a superb dupe for the usual nude or neutral.

Secondly, velvet teddy is warmer. The color is a darker shade of beige than the honeylove, with a darker shade of rose undertone. nevertheless, it can still pass as nude, if you are so inclined. Looking for a nude lipstick with just a little color to it, nothing elaborate? This is it.

 

Perfect Duplicates for Each Other…

Even with this difference, one can be a perfect dupe for the other. Whatever your skin tone is, MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy will go just fine with it.

Apart from this difference, these matte lipsticks are pretty much the same. They give you that natural yet not bare look. And they can go with any type of makeup, especially the smoky-eye look. They tone things down, sort of.

Additionally, their prices are close together. Both are high end lipsticks so if you are headed that way, buckle up with your money.

However, it is only fair that we point out one thing. The honeylove is in no way inferior to the velvet teddy. The velvet teddy is not an upgrade on the honeylove. Each stands as a classy lipstick on its own. Each can serve a purpose at any given time.

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Price and Value Ratio

 

Well, this depends on who is asking. Given the rave about them now, MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy are worth their prices. Taking from the feedback from users, they are just right for every occasion.

They are suitable for day and night and come on the lips with a few strokes. They are also good substitutes for lip colors that are toned down yet not completely invisible. A tube of either one could last for a while, so the prices may not be such a big deal.

But then, matte lip colors have the tendency to dry out quickly. And these lipsticks are complete matte, not semi. Even when they are applied with a lip balm base, they could still dry the lips. This is all part of the makeup of matte finishes.

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Comparison Table

 

Honeylove

Velvet Teddy

Finish MatteMatte
Color Light shade of beigeDark shade of beige
Texture Slightly creamySame as honeylove
Undertone Light roseDark rose
Skin Tone Almost all skin tonesAll skin tones
Weight 0.16 ounces0.32 ounces
 Get the MAC honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC velvet teddy lipstick now!

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Which Works Well for Whom and Where?

It is a given that some people may not be comfortable wearing MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks just about anywhere. And that is alright. Some people favor nude or neutral lip colors and can make them work just about anywhere. Others just have to have some bright colors to wear once in a while.

So which do you wear and when? Here are a few tips…

 

 

Honeylove

Velvet Teddy

This is a light shade of lipstick, very close to complete nude. Your skin tone plays a major role in deciding if you should wear it and when you should wear it.

 

Those with very pale skin may find it difficult to make this work. It does have a little color but you do not want a lipstick that would wash out your skin tone.

Tones…

A warmer skin tone would totally rock this, to any occasion. No jokes. You may have to add a little color to your eye makeup to even things out.

 

You could use a nude lip liner to give your lips a fuller look.

Everybody likes a dash of color sometimes, even if it is just a little. This lipstick goes with any skin tone, pale or dark.

 

Those with pale skin would totally make this work. This is because it does not draw attention their paleness yet, it adds some color to their general look.

Skin Tones…

Those with a darker skin tone would equally rock this. Whatever the occasion is, the velvet teddy is your go-to. It gives you the look of color without looking so flashy or all over the place.

 

To give you more plumped-up looking lips, you could equally use a nude lip liner or a lip plumper.

Get the MAC honeylove matte lipstick now!Buy the MAC velvet teddy matte lipstick now!

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Properties Common to Both

From what we have seen so far in this comparison, it is clear that there are a few things that differ between MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks. At least, they give each a personal identity.

In contrast to that, though, there are similarities that make it difficult to set them apart from each other. More so, these similarities could make choosing one easier. How? You would be using practically the same lipstick!

Texture

MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks both have the same texture. When applied, they feel somewhat creamy, not completely dry, as one would expect. Most noteworthy of everything else is the texture when first applied.

The overall feel during the time you wear it is a balance between matte and creamy. That is, you know you have a matte lipstick on but it does not leave your lips feeling like you just through the park with your mouth agape.

Nevertheless, there are a few people whose lips dry out from using either one of them. Mind you, this is not the case for everyone, just a few people.

However, this could mean that they have naturally dry lips. If that is the case with you, you may want use a lip balm as a base before applying. Or you could use a little of it on top of the lipstick of your choice.

Generally, though, MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks are not known to leave the lips dry.

Staying Power

Because they are not full-on matte lipsticks, MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks do not flake for most people or peel off. They are not completely dry.

Due to this, they have the ability to stay on the lips for a while. It is up to you to re-apply whenever you want. But you do not have to worry about flaking or peeling, as are usual with matte lipsticks.

 

 

In contrast, the velvet teddy has the tendency to not last as long as the honeylove. For whatever reason, some users have complained that it does not last; it cleans off fast. Some even doubt that it is from MAC.

Coupled with the fact they are shades of nude, it wouldn’t be such a big deal if they clean off. Even the slightest bit of it would not be missed.

Skin Tone

MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipstick are just right for all skin tones. Well, in the case of honeylove, we can say it suits almost all skin tones.

This is because it is paler than the velvet teddy. And because of this, those with very pale or light skin tones may find it difficult to pull off. Just as not everyone can pull off black or navy lipsticks, not everyone can comfortably wear the honeylove.

The velvet teddy is somewhat darker in tone, or warmer as some may say. Due to this, it is easier to wear than the honeylove. This is mostly why it is preferred more highly than the other.

Whether you are fair or dark, the velvet teddy would sit well on you. You would not feel your face is bare; it will leave you with just enough color to keep you comfortable. There is nothing extravagant about its hue.

Finish

As the title clearly shows, MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy lipsticks are both matte, none more than the other. However, they are not complete matte because they have a slightly creamy texture to them.

Complete matte or retro matte lipsticks are very dry, with no creaminess or satiny feeling to them. Usually, when they are worn, the wearers use a lip balm to avoid having lips that are totally dried out.

Nevertheless, from the look and feel, you can tell that these two are semi-matte. So you can choose to wear a balm with them or not. This depends on the type of lips you have. If you have naturally dry or very dry lips, a lip balm may very well be needed.

Scent

Both the MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks have a light scent that smells like vanilla. They are sweet and attractive. This scent seems to be a trademark for all MAC lipsticks and it sets them apart.

While this scent is pleasing and nice to a lot of users, there are some that do not like this. They do not like any smell in their lipsticks.

As perfect as both lipsticks may be, if you are one of those who would rather not have any scent to your lipsticks, then you may have to think twice about this.

Nonetheless, they both serve their purposes and the scents are light enough to be overlooked. If you can do this, then you are good to go.

Package

These two lipsticks come in the same tube shape and color. There is practically nothing distinguishable, one from the other. The only way to tell them apart is from the bottom of the tubes. That is where the names are indicated.

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Properties Unique to Each

As similar as the MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy lipsticks may appear, there are still distinguishing properties. These properties set them apart, one from the other. Below are those properties…

Undertone

The two lipsticks have different undertones. While the honeylove has a light rose undertone, the velvet teddy has a darker rose undertone.

These varying undertones give each lipstick a different hue or outcome. The dark rose undertone makes the velvet teddy have a warmer color. And the light rose undertone gives the honeylove a more natural and pale hue.

Color

Due to the different undertones, MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy lipsticks have different colors, albeit just slightly different.

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Unique Pros

Let us take a look at the pros which are unique to each tube of lipstick…

Pros Unique to the MAC Honeylove Lipstick

Almost-Nude Color

This feature is a plus, if you need a lipstick that is not completely nude. You see, you could pick up your tube of nude or neutral lipstick but may want just a little color to it. At times like that, you could be tempted to use a little lip color as a base.

But with this, it will not be necessary to do that. Even though it is nude, it is not completely so. The slight color makes all the difference. Those who would rather go with nude than with any other color would find the honeylove very appealing.

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

Pros Unique to the MAC Velvet Teddy Lipstick

Color

Placed side by side with the honeylove, the velvet teddy would almost always be chosen. The color endears it to many because it gives just a hint of color without being extravagant.

It also does not make the wearer look washed out, unlike most nude lipsticks. So it gives a choice of a little color with a lipstick that is usually classified as nude.

Skin Tone

The velvet teddy is suitable for every skin tone. As has been stated before, nude or neutral lipsticks have a way of making the face look bare. But that is not so with the velvet teddy, even though it is classified as nude.

 

 

Therefore, whether you are pale-skinned or not, the velvet teddy lipstick is yours for the picking. It will suit you just the way you want it, and for whatever occasion.

Cons Unique to the MAC Honeylove Lipstick

Skin Tone

The fact that this lipstick is not exactly suitable for every skin tone is already a disadvantage. Pale-skinned people would look even paler with it, despite the slight color to it.

Cons Unique to the MAC Velvet Teddy Lipstick

Not Long-lasting

The MAC velvet teddy lipstick may not last as long as the honeylove. And this is not a good feature for a high end lipstick.

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Pros Which Are Common to Both

 

Honeylove Lipstick

Velvet Teddy Lipstick

Slightly CreamyMAC honeylove lipstick is matte but not full-on matte.

 

Because of this, it does not dry out the lips unnecessarily.

 

Equally, its creaminess is not much. It is just little.

This slight creaminess is also applicable to the MAC velvet teddy lipstick.
Occasion In addition to the above, it is right to be worn for every occasion.

 

Be it day or night, you can wear it to any even and pair it with any outfit.

More so than the honeylove, the velvet teddy is just perfect for just any event or outfit.

 

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – Cons Which Are Common to Both

 

Honeylove Lipstick

Velvet Teddy Lipstick

Expensive A user asked if the price is for this lipstick is for one tube only. This is a very hilarious question but valid.

 

The price can deter a user from getting one because it is high end.

Similarly, the velvet teddy is expensive.
Not Easily AccessibleBecause it is a high end product, you are not likely to find it just about anywhere.

 

You cannot just walk into any drug store and find it. This may mean that you would have to go out of your way to buy one.

Likewise, the velvet teddy is not easily accessible.

 

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

 

It is important for us to add a note here. The MAC honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipstick are just that: matte. And even though they are not completely matte, they still have the tendency to have a drying effect.

If you have naturally dry or very dry lips, matte lipsticks may not be the best for you. This is because your lips need all the moisturizing lip products they can get. Putting any product on it which has a drying effect can be detrimental.

What can be done, though, if you really want to use one of these, is to always use a lip balm. You can apply it as base before you use it or apply it on top of the lipstick. During the day, you can check to be sure your lips are still balmy or creamy. This would ensure they do not dry out.

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – What Users Feel about Them

Honeylove Lipstick

Velvet Teddy Lipstick

Color

Firstly, there are more people who like the color than those who do not. At least, there is a gap in the figures accruing to both sides.

 

For some, the earthy tone is the attraction while for others, it is the reason for not buying it. People with very pale skin seem to have an aversion to it, despite the slight pigmentation it has.

 

What is more, some complained that the color they saw on receiving it was not what they expected. So disappointment sets in.

Texture

Then, there is the feel. There seems to be a high percentage of people who say it stays on for long and does not dry out their lips.

 

Finally, the price is something that many talked about. Of course, there were those who did not mind. But for others, they felt that if they have to pay so much for a tube of lipstick, it better be worth it. And there are a few who do not think it meets that criterion.

The velvet teddy has more customers than the honeylove. Maybe it is just about it having more color. Or maybe it has much more to do with Kylie Jenner wearing it at some point.
Better Color

Whatever the case, it is the rave among trend-setters and nude lipstick lovers. It gives the option of having some color in nude lipsticks without having to do anything extra or going overboard.

 

However, this lipstick seems to wear off quicker than its counterpart, the honeylove. Whatever the reason for this is, it does not sit well with many users. They complained that for what they pay for it, it should not be that way.

 

Nevertheless, as long as it stays on, it gives a nice feel to the lips. It does not dry it out, especially if a lip balm is used.

Versatile

And it is suitable for any occasion, even more so than the honeylove. The edge of color it has over the honeylove makes all the difference to many users.

 

 

mac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticksmac honeylove vs velvet teddy matte lipsticks
Get the MAC Honeylove lipstick now!Buy the MAC Velvet Teddy lipstick now!

MAC Honeylove vs Velvet Teddy Matte Lipsticks – What We Have to Say

Honeylove Lipstick

Velvet Teddy Lipstick

Staying Power

Firstly, we like that this lipstick seems to have a better staying power than the velvet teddy. There is no particular reason for this. It is just that if someone is going to pay a certain amount for a tube of lipstick, it has to stay on for long.

 

But we do not like that it is constantly placed side by side with the velvet teddy. This does not give it the chance to shine in its own right. It is really good lipstick from MAC. But people cannot help but compare both constantly.

Texture

Then we also like the texture on the lips and the effect it has on them. It makes the lips look fuller and plump. What is the point of any lip color if it does not give this effect?

 

Is there a particular reason why it is so pricey? We know that any skincare product that is priced high is so because of ingredients. But there are tubes of lipsticks that cost less but have exactly the same effect. We think it should cost a little less.

 

In all, we can boldly recommend this lipstick if you are in the market for nude lipstick.

 

Get the MAC honeylove matte lipstick now!

Color

Just like the honeylove, we like the color. Maybe we like it a little more than that of the honeylove.

 

The reason is because it gives more presence to the wearer. They do not fade into the background yet, they are not all up in your face. It is just the right shade for anyone who needs nude but with color.

 

Additionally, we think it would be better if it sold on its own strength alone. That is, let it sell based on its merits alone. People would see it better that way.

Perfect for Every Skin tone

Anybody can wear this lipstick. No matter how pale your skin is, you can wear the velvet teddy confidently. We like this.

 

But we do not like that sometimes, the color you see in the picture is not what you get. It can be disheartening.

 

And like the honeylove, it makes the lips look fuller when applied. While it gives the lips a blush look, it also it also adds volume.

 

We also recommend the velvet teddy for everyone, if you love nude lipsticks.

 

Buy the MAC velvet teddy matte lipstick now!

 

Ijeoma Chukwuemelie

I am your girl-next-door but there is nothing normal about me because normal is boring. I read a lot and I have a very active imagination. I like to travel, especially to places with ancient histories. There's so much to see, it's almost unbelievable. There is absolutely no price for awesomeness...or attractiveness, for that matter. And I am both.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Privacy Preference Center

    Necessary

    Advertising

    Analytics

    Other