 |
 |
Our eyes actually receive a lot of attention. Whether they’re teary, tired or you have that new eyeshadow on, people easily notice. So, in this article, we centre on MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded. These two are eyeshadows that certainly bring your eyes the right type of attention.
We know you’d like to head straight into the comparison, but we first have a brief background on eyeshadows.
Table of Contents
What Are Eyeshadows?
Eyeshadows are cosmetic products that adorn and brighten the eyelids. They contribute in making the overal makeup on the face look beautiful. This is especially so when the color of the eyes and eyeshadow complement each other. For example, blue eyes go hand in hand with coral shades and green eyes finely match browns.
Historically, eyeshadows came about for beauty and health purposes. They were also used for religious occasions in Egypt. But by the time they reached Rome and Greece, they were purely to beautify.
Types of Eyeshadows
The following are notable types of eyeshadows:
- Powder eyeshadow
- Liquid eyeshadow
- Cream eyeshadow
- Stick eyeshadow
- Loose pigment eyeshadow
Powder Eyeshadow
The powder eyeshadow is arguably the most popular kind of eyeshadow. It is easy to blend as well as remove or correct.
In other words, it is beginner-friendly. Usually, it is contained in a single pan but a palette is used if there is more than one. The finish can be either matte, satin or shimmer.
On the downside, the particles can fall outside the eye with ease. Also, it easily scatters once it falls on hard surfaces.
Liquid Eyeshadow
This eyeshadow has a similar feel and package with lip glosses. But this doesn’t mean it stays on moist. In fact, it dries quickly and remains in place.
As for advantages, it is hugely pigmented and travel-friendly. But although easy to use, it is difficult to build or mix. It is also not the best choice for oily lids because of how easily it creases.
Cream Eyeshadow
Just like the liquid ones, cream eyeshadows are long-lasting and have vibrant colors. However, they come in pots rather than tubes or pans.
They are particularly unique because they can serve as eye primer or highlighter. Blending these products is as easy as it gets and it can be done with the fingers. But this can be an unhygienic method. Another downside is they crease quite easily, too.
Stick Eyeshadow
This feels like a cream eyeshadow but in a stick form, soft and smooth. It is just as simple to blend and layer. The slender body undoubtedly has various advantages.
To start with, it fits in small spaces and is light to carry. Additionally, it colors the bottom lash-line without irritating the eye and can serve as eyeliner. Nevertheless, this richly pigmented eyeshadow may not stay intact or suit oily eyelids.
Loose Pigment Eyeshadows
Pigments fall into the extreme end of eyeshadow types. They are extremely pigmented and as a result, used mostly for showbiz and glamorous events. They build well and last okay. It’s best used on normal/oily skin and with a brush.
Comparison Overview – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
The Bare Study and Barely Branded may both be cream eyeshadows but they are different. At first glance, you can tell there’s some difference in their colors.
Furthermore, their staying power differs by a few hours. The Barely Branded significantly outlives the Bare Study when applied.
Nonetheless, we haven’t said these products have nothing in common. As much as they are good eyeshadows, they both do a fine job of highlighting.
Additionally, their packaging is very much alike. Both eyeshadows sit in glass pots with black lids that screw on.
Another similarity is that their textures blend better on lids that are not oily. But they are safe for all skin types as they are tested by dermatologists and ophthalmologists.
Finally, they both add shine to the lids or wherever they are used with their soft glitter. For instance, they can be placed on the nose or cheek.
As we proceed there’s surely more details on these points.
|
|
Price/Value Ratio – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Which of the eyeshadows adds more value for money?
Maybelline Barely Branded adds more value for money than MAC Bare Study. This is because it works not only as an eyeshadow but also as a highlighter and a primer. And while the Bare Study does almost same, the Barely Branded costs way less.
However, MAC Bare Study offers more shade options to choose from and suits every skin type, unlike Maybelline Barely Branded.
Comparison Table – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Bare Study |
Barely Branded |
|
| Size | 5oz/17g | 4oz/14g |
| Color | Soft beige | Champagne |
| Undertone | Gold pearl | N/A |
| Texture | Creamy | Creamy |
| Finish | Frost | Metallic Sheen |
| Package | Glass pot | Glass pot |
| Range | 10+ | 4 |
| Skin Tone | Every | Almost Every |
Video: A Closer Look at the MAC Bare Study
Whether you lean towards light makeup or otherwise, MAC Bare Study has something for everyone. Below, you’ll clearly see how pleasing the pigment is, in both subtle and heavy swatches. Also, you’ll see how effortlessly the reviewer applies this product with a finger.
Who Is Each Best for? – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
MAC Bare Study |
Maybelline Barely Branded |
| People with oily eyelids don’t always have to boycott cream eyeshadows like the Bare Study. Instead, they should keep a primer close-by in order for it to stay put noticeably. | This eyeshadow on its own is undoubtedly fit for a day look. At night, it will work better as a base, or heavily applied to show as much shimmer as possible. |
| If you are often in a rush, this product will not fail you. Since it is easy to blend, even with just a finger, this is a true time-saver right here. | Those with skin tones that are golden or somewhat yellow may want to seek other options. This is because it’s very similar to their skin and can be hard to notice. |
| The frost finish easily shows crease. So, it is essential to moisturize eyelids properly. And it is best used on wrinkle-free skin. | Additionally, this product is best applied with your fingers. You won’t find brushes giving the same effect. |
|
|
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comprehensive Comparison
Revlon Gel Envy vs Sally Hansen Gel Nail Polishes — In-depth Comparison
Clinique Moisture Surge Extended Thirst Relief vs Intense Hydrator – Detailed Comparison
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer Light vs Fair – Which Do You Prefer?
Common Features – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
The following are clear similarities between both eyeshadows:
- Packaging
- Texture
- Staying power
- Pigmentation
- Skin type
- Dermatologically-tested
- Ophthalmologically-tested
- Finish
Packaging
Many cream eyeshadows are found in pots. Usually, these pots are either plastic or glass, with a plastic cover. These covers ordinarily secure the content in the pot and keep air out. Also, the transparent pots make it easier for both potential buyers and owners to identify the color.
Both the Bare Study and Barely Branded have a glass pot that is convenient but a tad heavy.
Texture
The two products being compared have a creamy texture. This chiefly hints that they are easy to work with. In addition, they are both gentle on the skin.
Staying Power
Which has a better staying power?
Maybelline Barely Branded has a better staying power than MAC Bare Study. The Barely Branded lasts for up to 10 hours while the Bare Study lasts for about 6 hours.
However, when used as a base, they help other eyeshadows last longer too.
Pigmentation
Whether applied lightly or layered, both eyeshadows have pleasant colors. Besides, they complement other eyeshadows they are combined with.
Skin Type
What skin type is each eyeshadow suitable for?
The eyeshadows are suitable for different skin types. But MAC Bare Study fits all skin types while Maybelline Barely Branded fits almost all skin types.
An oily lid needs more attention when using these products. This is because the silky texture on oily skin can be slippery to apply. However, primers make a whole lot of difference.
Dermatologically-Tested
When it comes to preventing and treating skin conditions, dermatologists are the go-to. That is, they would know the effect any product would have on the skin.
Therefore, as tested products, it’s expected that the Bare Study and Barely Branded cause no harm to the skin.
Ophthalmologically-Tested
The cost of beauty should surely not be one’s health. Since Bare Study and Barely Branded meant to be used around the eyes, an eye doctor’s review is essential. Hence, users feel confident to use them around their eyes. To discover more on safe eye products, see this article or check this one here.
Finish
The shimmer in both products is not overpowering. A single use of each eyeshadow gives a subtle sheen. It can be built to be more obvious if so desired.
What’s more, their shimmer is handy for highlighting different parts of the face.
|
|
Unique Features – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Lasting Time
MAC Bare Study on an average stays 5-6 hours with creasing. Although including a primer assures longer wear. Whereas, Maybelline Barely Branded promises up to 10 hours of remaining crease-free.
Other Uses
The Bare Study is known for working adequately as a primer for different kinds of eyeshadows.
But the Barely Branded serves as a great highlighter. More often than not, it’s even smoother as a highlighter than an eyeshadow. For powder eyeshadows, it can replace a traditional eye primer.
Unique Pros – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Unique Pros of the MAC Bare Study
i. It comes with a lot of content in the jar. So, it doesn’t run out quickly.
ii. Also, the texture is softer than Barely Branded. It is, therefore, easier to blend.
Unique Pros of the Maybelline Barely Branded
i. This product is especially longlasting.
ii. Additionally, it’s more affordable than the Bare Study and many of its counterparts.
Video: Using the Maybelline Barely Branded
If you fall in love with the Barely Branded to use it alone, that’s absolutely great! But if you want to take it to the next level, this user will show you how.
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer Light vs Fair – Which Do You Prefer?
Clinique 7-Day Scrub vs Exfoliating Scrub – Extensive Comparison
Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3 — Which Should You Buy?
Unique Cons – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Unique Cons of the MAC Bare Study
i. The Bare Study without a doubt is a pricey product.
ii. Secondly, it is quite unflattering on dry lids.
Unique Con of the Maybelline Barely Branded
i. This eyeshadow does not blend greatly with a brush as with one’s fingers. Therefore, those highly conscious of germs might dislike this.
|
|
Common Pros – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Bare Study |
Barely Branded |
|
| Pigmentation | The MAC Bare Study has a fine pigment that can readily fit any skin tone. | In the same way, it has an impressive colour. |
| Durability | It lasts several hours altogether. | It equally lasts for many hours. |
| Dermatologist-tested | This product has been tested by experts, confirming it safe on the skin. | Barely Branded is also tested by a skin doctor. |
| Ophthalmologist-tested | What’s more, it has been deemed fit to use on the lids. | In similar fashion, it has been tested by an ophthalmologist. |
| Easy to Use | This eyeshadow is rather beginner-friendly. | Likewise, it is not difficult to apply. |
| Container | The glass pot takes a lot to break completely. | Similarly, it has a solid container. |
| Multipurpose | It’s otherwise used as a primer, not only as an eyeshadow. | It can also be a highlighter or primer. |
|
|
Common Cons – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
|
|
Bare Study |
Barely Branded |
|
Glass property
Moisture loss
Crease
Unhygienic |
The glass pot may crack if it mishandled or falls. Furthermore, it is a bit heavy and not the most travel friendly.
As time passes, it becomes less creamy. Hence, takes more effort to work with.
It commonly creases on oily eyelids.
Lastly, regular dipping of fingers into the container can be quite unhygienic. |
Barely Branded’s glass pot is thick thus; not so easy to carry around.
The lid needs to be tightly screwed because it dries up easily.
Generally, this product is less effective on oily lids.
Brushes are a cleaner alternative, but it blends better with the finger. |
Users’ Feeling – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
Bare StudyA lot of users are satisfied with this product because it’s lightweight and has a lovely color. This is especially so for those needing something subtle. So far, users are impressed that the Bare Study lasts through strenuous activities and exercise without wearing out. But it seems like it’s much less favourable on oily lids. After using a primer though, many customers have a more positive feedback. Still, a few of them with oily lids discontinue use. Another issue this product frequently has is on thinner skin. Older users complained that the shimmer reflected poorly on their skin. |
Barely BrandedIts quality, being similar to a higher brand rather than drugstore, is highly praised among customers. Users also enjoy its staying power and tasteful color. Many of them like the amount of shimmer in it as well. However, most users with golden skin tones find themselves disappointed, to say the least. For them, it was basically invisible. Customers with oilier lids didn’t enjoy the longlasting wear like others. |
Our Take – MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded
The Bare Study indeed met some of our expectations. But we hoped for its price, it would last much longer after application. Then again, it won us over with its nice color. Plus, it is professionally tested.
As for the Barely Branded, we are eager to recommend because of its staying power and color. And yes, the price is delightful.
|
|
MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded – Frequently Asked Questions
Does Eyeshadow Make Any Difference?
Wearing eyeshadow makes a difference to the overall appearance of your makeup and face. More specifically, using the right blend of colors for your skin tone and eye color will make all the difference.
It will enhance your eyes and make whatever color of lipstick you use to pop. For example, wearing a dark brown eyeshadow with lighter browns towards the inner corners of your eyes will give your eyes a different shape.
Using dark colors as eyeshadow and combining with red lipstick will give you smoky and mysterious look.
What Does Eyeshadow Do to Your Eyes?
Eyeshadow makes your eyes pop. This is especially true if you have an unusual eye color. Using the right blend of colors in your eyeshadow will draw more of the right kind of attention to your eyes. It will also add more dimension and depth and enhance your eye color.
Additionally, it will make your eyes look bigger than they usually are, in some cases. Generally, eyeshadows add completeness to your overall makeup and look. This is true if the makeup is properly done. Moreover, the occasion to which the makeup is worn matters.
What Are the Different Types of Eyeshadow?
The different ypes of eyeshadow are:
- Cream eyeshadow
- Powder eyeshadow
- Loose pigments/eyeshadow
- Stick eyeshadow
- Liquid eyeshadow
- Baked eyeshadow
Cream eyeshadows usually wear long and have a shimmery finish. But they melt easily.
Powder eyeshadows are the most common type of eyeshadows. They come in pans and palettes.
Loose pigments eyeshadows come in loose form and are dry and very pigmented.
Stick eyeshadows look like crayons and are easy to use.
Liquid eyeshadows look like lip gloss and are great for beginner makeup users.
Baked eyeshadows are very smooth and easily blendable. They are not pressed but baked.
Is It Bad to Get Eyeshadow in Your Eye?
It is bad to get eyeshadow in your eye. This is especially true if it is a constant occurrence. It could easily cause an eye infection that can worsen if it is not treated quickly and well.
The best practice is to clean off all types of eye makeup when you get home. And also clean off other facial makeup before going to bed. Sleeping with makeup on is detrimental to your skin. And if you rub your eyes in your sleep, you will get some of it in there.
Why Does My Eyeshadow Look Bad?
Your eyeshadow looks bad probably because you used the wrong colors for your skin tone and eye color. Another reason it looks bad is that you used too much of it, making it very difficult to blend it out.
Additionally, it is possible you are using the wrong type of eyeshadow for your skin type. As an example, if you have oily skin, using a cream eyeshadow will make your face look oilier. And using loose pigments eyeshadow for dy skin will make it look drier.
Do You Really Need Eyeshadow Primer?
You don’t really need eyeshadow primer. but it helps with keeping the eyeshadow intact and beautiful all day long.
If you want to keep your eyeshadow from wiping off easily or smudging quickly, an eyeshadow primer will come in handy. This is especially true if you have oily lids, where eyeshadow slips off easily.
And if you live in a hot and humid environment, this primer will help keep your eyeshadow in place. This saves you money and time from reapplication.
