Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory – Which Should You Go for?

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Foundation

 

A smooth and even base is the start of flawless makeup and look. If you get the base of your makeup right, every other part will go on easily. But if it is wrong, you will hardly get others right. Part of this base is the foundation. So we are looking at Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory.

Getting the right foundation for your skin type could prove difficult a lot of times. This is especially true as we grow older. You could find you have normal or oily when you are younger. But as you age, you may find your skin growing drier.

Sticking to one for many years is possible but not always doable. So you have to go with the flow of your changing skin. however, if you find your skin remains the same over the years, well, good for you.

The reason we mention the possibility of changing skin is the foundations under review. They are for two different skin types so give different results. You may want to check out both of them and see which your skin goes with more.

And those with combination skin could get both and use interchangeably if they decide to use these products. That way, you don’t stick to one when your skin demands another.

 

Table of Contents

Comparison Overview – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

The most notable difference between both foundations is the result they give. Practically every other thing is the same, down to the value of the SPF in them.

While the matte and poreless foundation keeps the face free from oil and shine, the dewy and smooth option gives the face a luminous glow.

The matte is for normal to oily skin types while the dewy is for normal to dry skin. What the matte does for oily skin is that it dries up excess oil and blurs the appearance of pores. It gives the face a clean and opaque look without making it look too artificial.

The dewy foundation, on the other hand, gives dry skin a glow. It makes the face look smooth and slightly moist, without looking oily. The smoothness it gives almost gives you the impression you are looking at glass.

Due to the fact it is meant for dry skin, the dewy foundation moisturizes it as it is worn as foundation. It keeps the skin hydrated so that at the end of the day, dry skin doesn’t get drier.

Making a choice between these two could pose a problem for someone with combination skin. Dry and oily patches could prove daunting to handle. So how do you make the right choice? You are about to learn it.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Foundation

Buy this Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation on Amazon

Buy this Maybelline New York Fit Me Dewy+Smooth foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Price/Value Ratio – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

For drugstore foundations, the reviews are amazing. They cost so little yet give so much value to users. If you are not careful, you may end up using them alone. Nothing wrong with that, though.

The value they offer outweighs the price. Of course, you don’t expect to get so much from drugstore products. People usually buy them as dupes, so as not to quickly run out of the more expensive products.

But these products give about the same result as some of the higher-end options. Even though there is the chance of oxidization or wearing off quickly, you still get a few good hours in. That is saying a lot for products that cost so little.

 

Comparison Table – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

 

Matte + Poreless

Dewy + Smooth

Skin TypeNormal to OilyNormal to Dry
Finish MatteDewy
SPF Value1818
Coverage BuildableNot Buildable
Consistency Slightly ThickRunny
Formula Not SpecifiedGel-based

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

 

Who Is Each One Best for? – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

Matte + Poreless

Dewy + Smooth

The matte option is best for those with oily or normal skin. It holds in the shine for hours and keeps the skin looking fresh, not tired or sweaty.

 

If you have visible pores you’d rather hide, you can use this foundation. It blurs the appearance of pores and gives the face an overall clean and flawless look.

 

Also, if you have normal skin but would like a foundation that can be built, this is for you. This goes better with people who tend to wear full-on makeup regularly. Besides, it stays in place for a long time.

 

Nevertheless, people with combination skin can also use it. If you tend to have dry and oily patches, you could mix this with a setting powder. To keep the dry areas from flaking, you could apply some moisturizer before application.

On the flip side, the dewy option is great for those with dry or normal skin. Normal skin seems to enjoy the best of both worlds, hmmm?

 

It adds moisture and visible luminosity to dry skin that lasts for hours. This ensures it doesn’t get flaky or cakey as time wears on.

 

It doesn’t make the face shine, no. rather, it gives a glow that removes the possibility of patches. Go for this if you have dry skin.

 

Those with normal skin who tend to favour lighter makeup would fare better with this option. It is lighter in consistency than the matte so offers a lighter coverage.

 

In the same way, the dewy foundation can be used by those with dry and oily combination skin. Use a setting powder to keep the oily zones from going crazy during the day and keep everything in place with a good setting spray.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Foundation

Buy this Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation on Amazon

Buy this Maybelline New York Fit Me Dewy+Smooth foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Common Features – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

Here, we show you what features both foundations have in common. Why is one confused for the other, if not closely looked at?

 

Color and Shade

The two foundations come in the same color, 120 Classic Ivory. This color is perfect for you if you have fair skin. note that we did not say very fair skin. this is because there are lighter colors than the classic ivory.

The shades, or undertones, are the same, too. They both have cool undertones. However, this doesn’t have anything to do with the color; there are lighter colors that have neutral and warm undertones. But they both have the same color and shade.

 

Easy Application and Blending

Even though the matte is slightly thicker than the dewy foundation, both of them are still easy to apply. In the same vein, they are easy to get blended. When you buy the right color and shade for your skin tone, you will find that they fit in well. With your fingers or a sponge, you will get them to go into the right places. They will usually not accentuate lines or creases if this is done well.

 

Packaging

The matte and dewy foundations come in the same type of capped bottles. You will have to twist off the caps before you can get some of the contents out.

The bottles are made of glass and are clear. But at the same time, they are light so are not hard to carry around. And the foundations’ different designations are boldly inscribed on them.

 

SPF

With both foundations having an SPF value of 18, they offer the same degree of protection from the sun. one does not offer more protection than the other. However, the sunscreen is not indicated as being broad spectrum, which is the better kind.

 

No Clogging of Pores

For either the matte or the dewy foundation, your pores will not get clogged. Clogged pores lead to skin that can’t breathe. And this in turn, would lead to breakouts and other things. The foundations don’t clear clogged pores but they don’t contribute to them, either.

 

Hypoallergenic

For the most part, people with sensitive skin can even use either of them. They are safe and gentle on the skin. But if you are allergic to parabens, you may want to tread carefully.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Fit Me Dewy + Smooth Foundation, 120 Classic Ivory, 1 Fl. Oz (Count of 1) (Packaging May Vary)

Buy this Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation on Amazon

Buy this Maybelline New York Fit Me Dewy+Smooth foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Unique Features – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

 

Coverage

The matte foundation offers better coverage and is buildable. You can add layers to get a better-than-medium coverage if that is what you want.

The dewy foundation, on the other hand, is not quite buildable. This means it offers more of a natural and light finish than the matte foundation.

 

Video: A First Look at the Matte + Poreless Foundation

Not sure what the final look would be like with this foundation? Take a look at this video…

 

 

Consistency

The dewy foundation is runny, meaning that it is very light. While the matte foundation is not very thick, it is also not runny. It has a balanced consistency that makes it buildable and its coverage better.

 

Sunscreen

While both foundations contain SPF, there is a slight difference. The lighter colors of the dewy foundation contain SPF while the darker shades don’t.

We don’t want to postulate but the reason could be because of pigmentation, or lack of it. Darker skin has better pigmentation so is usually less prone to sunburn than lighter skin. And since the darker colors are meant for dark skin, the need for SPF may not have been seen.

 

Formula

The base formula of the matte is not exactly indicated. But the dewy foundation has a gel-like base, giving it that glossy feel and look. Besides, gel is more water than anything else so it helps keep dry skin hydrated.

 

Unique Pros – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

 

Unique Pros of the Matte + Poreless Foundation

 

Better Coverage

The matte foundation offers better coverage. It does a better job of covering blemishes and spots. So even if you chose not to use a concealer, it could still give you decent coverage to last you a while. What’s more, this coverage can be taken from natural to full. Its consistency contributes to make this possible.

 

Prevents Shine

The finish, which is matte, prevents your face from getting the dreaded shine on oily zones. It gives you a clean look for as long as you have it on, keeping oil under control.

 

Poreless Look

While it controls the shine, it also hides visible pores. Even close up, your face gets an almost-flawless look. It doesn’t minimize pores permanently but diminishes their appearance.

 

All Colors Contain SPF

Every color under the matte foundation, both light and dark, contains SPF. No skin color is left out of getting protection from the sun, no matter how little.

 

Unique Pros of the Dewy + Smooth Foundation

 

Hydrates the Skin

Apart from working as a foundation, it does not contribute to the dryness of the skin. This is common with many other foundations for dry skin.

Instead, it keeps the skin moisturized and hydrated, reducing the feel of dryness. Even when you take it off, you don’t get dry patches on your face.

 

Video: A First Look at the Dewy + Smooth Foundation

For those with very dry skin, here is what you get when you use this option. Nice or what?

 

 

Natural Finish

If you are going for a more natural or light look with your makeup, this foundation will help you achieve that. Even though it is not very buildable, it still does a good job of covering without overdoing it. The result you get is a light, more natural ‘this is all me’ look.

 

Luminous Glow

Above all else, it doesn’t get flaky or cake while you wear it. Your face takes on a glow that you don’t get normally. People would hardly know you have dry skin.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Foundation

Buy this Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation on Amazon

Buy this Maybelline New York Fit Me Dewy+Smooth foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Unique Cons – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

 

Unique Cons of the Matte + Poreless Foundation

 

Can Dry Too Fast

Even with oily skin, the matte foundation could dry a little too fast. You may find that during the day, it begins to feel matted. And if you have dry skin, this could be worse.

 

Unique Cons of the Dewy + Smooth Foundation

 

Runny Consistency

Its consistency makes it difficult to build it to full coverage. This is not necessarily bad but you may find it is too light to offer the coverage you need.

 

Limited Colors with SPF

The lighter colors come with sun protection factor. But the darker colors have none. We don’t exactly know why this is so but it is what it is.

 

Common Pros – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

 

Matte + Poreless

Dewy + Smooth

Hypoallergenic It is suitable to be used even by those with sensitive skin. This makes its claim to being hypoallergenic seem to be true. And that is an entirely good thing. Potential users who react easily to ingredients can rest assured in this.In the same vein, the Dewy option is hypoallergenic.
Easy Application and BlendingThe foundation is not too thick that it takes some effort to be applied and blended. There is no trick to using it. And it blends easily with your fingers or with a sponge.The same is applicable to this product.
Non-comedogenicThere is little or no chance of getting clogged pores. It leaves your pores free and is also easy to wash off.Similarly, this foundation contains ingredients with little or no comedogenic properties.
Sunscreen With SPF 18, you get a good enough protection from the sun on your face. Using extra sunscreen on your face would only be by choice, not a necessity.Likewise, this option contains exactly the same SPF value.
Superb BaseThe product offers a great base for any makeup type. It is not too heavy that it swallows other products. And it doesn’t cause other makeup to slide off your face halfway through the day.The same applies to the Dewy foundation.
Affordable Oh, it is so affordable. For what it’s worth, you lose nothing even if you end up not liking it much. That is how affordable it is.This product is equally really affordable.
Staying PowerWithout any deliberate or accidental attempt to clean it off, the foundation can stay for as long as 5-6 hours.The Dewy works in the same way.
Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Foundation

Buy this Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation on Amazon

Buy this Maybelline New York Fit Me Dewy+Smooth foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Common Cons – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

 

Matte + Poreless

Dewy + Smooth

Cleans off too QuickExcept you use a setting spray, the foundation has the tendency to clean easily. This is different from its staying power. If there is no accidental brush against your face, it can stay on for hours. But if there is a brush against it, a chunk of it will get wiped off.The same applies to the Dewy foundation.
Package The bottle comes with a cap that has to be twisted off before use. This means there is no dispensing pump. Liquid products such as these need pumps. Without hem, there would be waste and a mess. Moreover, the content could become unhygienic.It also has no dispensing pump. As runny as this particular product is, a dispenser would have been better.
Oxidization The foundation could go a shade or two darker after you apply it. This could give you two different skin tones.Likewise, this product could oxidize after application.
Parabens While this is not a bad ingredient, some people do react to it terribly. And this foundation contains a bit of it.Similarly, it contains parabens.
Scent The foundation is free of any fragrance. But it still comes with a smell. Seeing as it goes on the face, you can understand how off-putting it can be for allergic users.The same is true of this product.

 

What Users Feel About Them – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

Matte + Poreless

Dewy + Smooth

Users like that it offers just as much coverage as higher-end options. And it stays for as long, or even longer. Why should they have to spend so much more to get just about the same results?

 

They also like that they get to save some money while getting a whole bunch of benefits.

 

Suitable for Other Skin Types

 

A user with sensitive skin could not believe how well her skin accepted the product. This is despite the fact it is meant for normal to oily skin. She liked that she did not react negatively to it, and that is saying a lot for a drugstore product.

 

They equally like how it is light on the skin yet can be built to any level they want. This flexibility gives them more room to choose what they want.

 

But they don’t like how quickly it dries. For some users, it made their skin flaky. Plus, the smell was not very welcome. They were also not crazy about the pump-less bottle. It could be unhygienic.

This foundation was used by someone with combination skin and she came out looking great. She described how she used it with setting powder to get that look. So users like that those with combination skin can equally use it.

 

Its lightness and dewy nature make it all the better for them. There is also the fact it is hard to cake on the face. This is due to its runny consistency and lightness.

 

Plus, it does not cause any reaction on sensitive skin. Even though it is listed for a certain skin type, it is clear others can use it. But it could creasy on oily skin. This may be due to too much oiliness or hydration.

 

What They Don’t Like

 

However, it wears off easily and has a drug-like smell, which was a turn-off for some users. Yes, it is fragrance-free but it still has some scent to it. And the lack of a dispensing pump was not something they liked. It caused too much messiness.

Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Classic Ivory, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free FoundationMaybelline New York Foundation

Buy this Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless foundation on Amazon

Buy this Maybelline New York Fit Me Dewy+Smooth foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

 

Our Verdict – Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory

Matte + Poreless

Dewy + Smooth

Oily skin has got a foundation to rest on, and an affordable one, no less. It is light to the touch and we like how it reduces the appearance of pores. It does what it says, a great advantage for any skincare or makeup product.

 

Additionally, we like that it stays put for hours and does not come off with sweat. But it is easy to be washed off at the end of the day.

 

But we don’t like that it is easily wiped off. That is, someone rubbing against it cleans it easily. And its packaging is not something we are ecstatic about.

 

In the end, would we recommend it? Yes, we would. For oily skin, this is a great product to try out.

Its smoothness and glow are superb. We like how it adds so much lustre and luminosity to dry skin. it leaves no patches anywhere.

 

We also like that it moisturizes dry skin along the way. The skin doesn’t have to be the worse for wear after the foundation comes off. In fact, it adds to the moisture the skin already has.

 

We don’t like the scent, though. And even though its lightness is commendable, it makes the foundation not buildable for some users.

 

What is our verdict for this product? It is a good one, for dry skin. Good for combination skin, too. We would recommend it if you want a foundation to complement what you already have. It is a superb buy.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Ijeoma Chukwuemelie

Ijeoma is a wife, career woman and skincare enthusiast who believes everyone deserves a chance at having healthy skin.Having battled skin conditions from a very young age and won, she is writing from experience.The aim is to give others a look at skincare products and routines that actually work.She actively writes at www.skincareproductsguide.com

Leave a Comment

Privacy Preference Center

    Necessary

    Advertising

    Analytics

    Other