Makeup Neutrogena vs

Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations – Which to Go for?

There is little else as great as having a foundation that works as medicine, in the skincare world. While your face glows from the foundation, it is also being treated at the same time. Who can say no to that? So we are comparing Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations.

 

Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Acne and Blemish Fighting Liquid Foundation with Salicylic Acid Acne Medicine, Shine Controlling, for Acne Prone Skin, 10 Classic Ivory, 1 fl. ozNeutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup Foundation, Broad Spectrum SPF 20 Sunscreen, Lightweight & Flawless Coverage Foundation with Antioxidant Vitamin E & Feverfew, Natural Ivory, 1 fl. oz

Wonderful was the day foundation was made. Many women today cannot step out of their houses without a little of it on their face. With so many types and shades available today, hardly anyone can say they didn’t find their fit.

How much more wonderful when you have a foundation that works as acne medicine at the same time. A perfect combination of beauty and health.

But when compared to another foundation without acne medicine, which should you go for? While one treats acne, the other gives you healthier-looking skin, even after you wash it off. So in both cases, you stand to gain beautifully flawless skin.

In this comparison, therefore, we will show you which path to take for the best results. At the end, you will have the information needed to make the best choice.

 

Table of Contents

Comparison Overview – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

The main differences between both foundations are the shades and the benefits. The SkinClearing option is for fair-skinned people. It has a neutral undertone so may be suitable for just about any fair-skinned person.

The Healthy Skin option is slightly warmer. So it would be more suitable for someone with a somewhat darker skin tone and warm undertone.

Even though they do not come from the same line of products, their shades are very close to each other. As has been mentioned before, classic ivory shade is slightly lighter than the natural ivory shade.

Second, the SkinClearing option treats acne over time. It contains salicylic acid as an active ingredient. But this does not mean you cannot use it if you don’t have acne. The coverage is medium so works just as well as any other foundation.

The Healthy Skin option, on the other hand, improves your skin’s texture, luminosity and tone. These add up to give you a healthy and beautiful glow over time.

Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Acne and Blemish Fighting Liquid Foundation with Salicylic Acid Acne Medicine, Shine Controlling, for Acne Prone Skin, 10 Classic Ivory, 1 fl. ozNeutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup Foundation, Broad Spectrum SPF 20 Sunscreen, Lightweight & Flawless Coverage Foundation with Antioxidant Vitamin E & Feverfew, Natural Ivory, 1 fl. oz
     Click to Buy the SkinClearing foundation on Amazon Click to Buy the Healthy Skin foundation on Amazon

 

Video: Does the SkinClearing Option Work on Acne?

This video shows if this option really works on acne and how well it does.

 

 

Price/Value Ratio – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

The results which have been gotten over time from both products outweigh their prices. Believe it or not, they are both drugstore foundations. Whatever else they may not get right, like not having a myriad of undertones, the benefits trump it all.

The difference in their prices is not much. Being pocket-friendly foundations, it is not a fuss to buy one at any time. Rest assured you will get more than enough value for your money.

 

Comparison Table – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

 

SkinClearing Foundation

Healthy Skin Foundation

Shade 10 Classic Ivory20 Natural Ivory
Undertone YellowPink
Oil ContentNoneNone
Benefits Acne TreatmentHealthier Skin
SPFNone20
Skin TypeOily, Combination and SensitiveAll
Fragrance NoYes

Prices and images pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:

 

Which Is Better for You? – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

SkinClearing Foundation

Healthy Skin Foundation

If your skin is prone to acne or you have a constant breakout, this option may work for you.

It is formulated with salicylic acid, which helps in fighting excess oil production and breakouts.

Everyone knows how light they are so if your skin is fair, the classic ivory would go well with your skin. It offers medium coverage but it is adequate to take you through the day.

However, it may not go so well with dry skin. This is because its makeup causes dryness. It would simply add to your already dry skin.

For a healthy glow and healthier skin over time, it is best you go with this option. It does not treat acne but it causes your skin to look younger the longer you use it.

It is suitable for every skin type so just about anyone can use it.

Additionally, it offers about medium coverage but leaves your skin to breathe. It does not give you a glassy or opaque look. You still look as natural as possible.

So if you are one to not wear heavy makeup, you may want to try this.

Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Acne and Blemish Fighting Liquid Foundation with Salicylic Acid Acne Medicine, Shine Controlling, for Acne Prone Skin, 10 Classic Ivory, 1 fl. ozNeutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup Foundation, Broad Spectrum SPF 20 Sunscreen, Lightweight & Flawless Coverage Foundation with Antioxidant Vitamin E & Feverfew, Natural Ivory, 1 fl. oz
     Click to Buy the SkinClearing foundation on Amazon Click to Buy the Healthy Skin foundation on Amazon

 

Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

Clinique Almost Powder vs Superpowder Foundations – Broad Comparison

CC Cream by Olay vs Maybelline Dream BB Cream– Detailed Comparison

MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner – Extensive Comparison

Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions – Thorough Comparison

Nars Radiant Creamy vs Maybelline Fit Me Concealers – Detailed Comparison

Maybelline Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting Concealers Radiant vs Ivory – Extensive Comparison

 

 

 

Common Features – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

With all the differences they have, there are a few features that make them similar.

 

Medium Coverage

Both foundations offer medium coverage. There is no indication that they are buildable but that does not mean it can’t be done. You can choose to layer on as lightly as you can.

However, they still leave you looking natural and fresh. They don’t leave you looking all masked-up or heavy on the face. If you are one to go for light makeup, these may be great options of foundations for you.

 

Lightweight

Because their consistency is runny, there is no weight to them. They are light to the feel and on the face. You would hardly know you have any on. And it works well with any other makeup product on it without feeling heavy.

 

Breathable

Their lightweight formula helps this to be possible. You see, if a foundation is heavy, the chances of that product being breathable are slim. It is more likely to block your pores and not allow your skin to breathe. But that is not the case with these two products.

 

Non-comedogenic

Due to the fact that they are breathable, your pores are not clogged. This is made even truer by the fact that they don’t contain a lot of ingredients with comedogenic properties. With either of them on your skin, other products have the opportunity to get into the skin and work.

 

Oil Content

Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations are oil-free. They both act as a treatment for the skin. If there is oil, especially for the skin-clearing option, it would defeat its acne-treatment claims.

The absence of oil aids in their performance to the maximum. Oil has its place in making your skin better but with these, there is no excess oil to cause a barrier on your skin.

 

No Caking

As they dry on your face and neck, they do not cake or crack. They remain in place, smooth and effective, for as long as you wear them. Again, this is aided by their lightweight nature.

Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Acne and Blemish Fighting Liquid Foundation with Salicylic Acid Acne Medicine, Shine Controlling, for Acne Prone Skin, 10 Classic Ivory, 1 fl. ozNeutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup Foundation, Broad Spectrum SPF 20 Sunscreen, Lightweight & Flawless Coverage Foundation with Antioxidant Vitamin E & Feverfew, Natural Ivory, 1 fl. oz
     Click to Buy the SkinClearing foundation on Amazon Click to Buy the Healthy Skin foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Unique Features – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

In the section ‘Comparison Overview, we listed the main differences between both products. These same points set each apart from the other.

 

What They Do

The SkinClearing formula is made to treat acne and stop it from recurring. Salicylic acid, which is the acne medicine the foundation contains, gets through fast into the skin through the Micro Clear technology.

This technology works to clear pores and remove oil barriers so the medicine can gain free entrance to combat acne. This foundation is the first and only type with this technology. It is superbly unique.

On the other hand, the Healthy Skin formula does not treat acne. Instead, it works on making the skin look healthy and young with time. With the presence of broad-spectrum SPF 20, your skin is protected from the sun.

The damage that would have accumulated from constant sun rays on the skin is eliminated by the sunscreen. Titanium dioxide, which is the sunscreen, is the active ingredient in the foundation.

 

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VB4g-Y4wwSw

 

 

Unique Pros – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

 

Unique Pros of the SkinClearing Foundation

 

Contains Salicylic Acid

This is one of the best ingredients with which to treat acne. And it happens to the active ingredient in the foundation. This makes it super effective as a treatment without taking away from its foundation duties.

 

Micro Clear Technology

This technology, unique to Neutrogena, aids the entrance of salicylic acid into the skin to combat acne. It does this by cutting through the oil and every other barrier to get the medicine to the acne source.

 

Great for Sensitive Skin

This type of skin is one of the most difficult to please. However, this foundation fits perfectly well with sensitive skin. It does not cause breakouts nor any allergic reaction. It has been testified to by many users with sensitive skin.

 

Pros Unique to Healthy Skin Foundation

 

Broad Spectrum SPF

This is no ordinary sun protection factor. Broad-spectrum means it offers protection from both UVA and UVB rays. That is a wider coverage and gives better protection than SPF with broad spectrum.

 

Fits All Skin Types

It can be used by just about anyone, even those with oily skin. That is usually a hard feat to achieve, given that sensitive and combination skin types are hard to handle.

 

Unique Cons – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

 

Cons Unique to the SkinClearing Foundation

 

No Sunscreen

It would have fared better as an acne treatment if it has some sunscreen. It would have adequately protected the skin from harmful rays of the sun.

 

Cons Unique to the Healthy Skin Foundation

 

Contains Fragrance

Fragrance can be harmful to the skin. It has been known to cause irritation and allergic reactions. Even if it comes in a small amount in any product, there is still a chance of someone reacting to it.

 

Need for Reapplication

You may need to reapply it from time to time, depending on how your skin fares under it. This is to keep the sunscreen at maximum functioning capacity. But this could prove to be an inconvenience, especially when you have to constantly be on the move.

 

Common Pros – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

 

SkinClearing Formula

Healthy Skin Formula

Breathable It is a breathable formula. That is, it does not cover skin to prevent it from breathing. This is one of the main reasons your skin won’t break out.The same is applicable to this option.
Non-comedogenicSecond, it does not clog pores. Open pores aid skin to breathe and also receive other skincare products. They also stop breakout on the skin.In the same way is the Healthy Skin option non-comedogenic.
Lightweight Its lightweight formula makes it easy to wear all day without the feeling of heaviness. You can wear other makeup products on top of it easily.Similarly, this option comes as lightweight.
No CakingAll through the day, it wears easy and does not crack nor become cakey. It remains smooth for as long you have it on.Likewise, the Healthy Skin foundation does not cake.
Oil ContentThere is little or no oil to create a harmful barrier on the skin. Active ingredients have free entrance into your skin.The same applies to this option.
Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Acne and Blemish Fighting Liquid Foundation with Salicylic Acid Acne Medicine, Shine Controlling, for Acne Prone Skin, 10 Classic Ivory, 1 fl. ozNeutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup Foundation, Broad Spectrum SPF 20 Sunscreen, Lightweight & Flawless Coverage Foundation with Antioxidant Vitamin E & Feverfew, Natural Ivory, 1 fl. oz
     Click to Buy the SkinClearing foundation on Amazon Click to Buy the Healthy Skin foundation on Amazon

 

Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded – Extensive Comparison

Clinique Even Better vs Beyond Perfecting Foundations – Detailed Comparison

Garnier BB Cream vs Maybelline BB Cream – Extensive Comparison

Ambi Skincare Fade Cream vs Clinique Even Better Dark Spot Corrector – Extensive Comparison

MAC Pro Longwear Vs Revlon Colorstay Foundations – Detailed Comparison

Makeup Forever Ultra HD vs Revlon Photoready Foundations — Extensive Comparison

 

 

 

Common Cons – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

 

SkinClearing Foundation

Healthy Skin Foundation

Package Nevertheless, it comes in a bottle without a pump to dispense the very liquid content. Because of this, it could get really messy and could be wasted.Similarly, the Healthy Skin comes in a pump-less bottle so could be wasteful.
Affordability For the price, it could come with a somewhat bigger content. But it does not. Depending on how you use it, you may run out of the product quickly and suddenly.The same is applicable to this foundation.

 

What People Feel – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

SkinClearing Formula

Healthy Skin Formula

It is more generally favored because it treats acne. Even people who don’t have any acne to treat veers toward this option.
Skin Suitability 

The fact it is suitable for sensitive skin also endears to many users. They like how light and free it feels on their skin, as opposed to the heaviness and opacity of some other products.

Not that it is advisable to do that but one user said she fell asleep with it on her face but had no reaction. This is despite having sensitive and acne-prone skin. That is how great it is on her skin.

The ease with which it glides on cuts down the time spent on applying makeup and that is a plus for different users.

So, apart from not having any sunscreen and coming in a bottle without a pump, users feel it is a great package at a reasonable price.

Sunscreen

The presence of sunscreen is an advantage for many users. Not just that it has sunscreen but the broad-spectrum type of up to 20. That is adequate sunscreen for protection.

This is added to its work as a foundation. So while they use it as makeup, it doubles as sunscreen. No need to use any extra. That saves time and money for many of them.

This is why a user, who is usually outdoors, found this option a superb one. It lasts a long time and gave her just the right coverage without being too much. That is a strong testimony to its efficacy.

But the fragrance proved a problem to users who are allergic. It caused a headache for a user. Plus, the bottle could get messy over time. This is because it has no dispenser.

 

Neutrogena SkinClearing Oil-Free Acne and Blemish Fighting Liquid Foundation with Salicylic Acid Acne Medicine, Shine Controlling, for Acne Prone Skin, 10 Classic Ivory, 1 fl. ozNeutrogena Healthy Skin Liquid Makeup Foundation, Broad Spectrum SPF 20 Sunscreen, Lightweight & Flawless Coverage Foundation with Antioxidant Vitamin E & Feverfew, Natural Ivory, 1 fl. oz
     Click to Buy the SkinClearing foundation on Amazon Click to Buy the Healthy Skin foundation on Amazon

 

 

 

Our Take – Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations

SkinClearing Foundation

Healthy Skin Foundation

We believe it is a great product. The combination of salicylic acid, which is a proven acne treatment, and the foundation is a clever one. Makeup does not have to be a one-way street anymore.

The Micro Clear technology which boosts the efficacy of the acne treatment makes it even better for us. You don’t have to do all the work yourself. The technology clears away oil barriers and other things so that the medicine can work fully. What more can we ask for?

However, if the package can change to come in a bottle with a pump or have an applicator, it would seal the deal. The messiness is deal-breaker for many.

In summary, it is a yes for us, especially if you are prone to have breakouts.

We like that it has sunscreen of the broad-spectrum type. While functioning as a foundation, it doubles also as a sunscreen. The most active ingredient in it is titanium dioxide, which is sunscreen.

It stays in place for as long as you wear it, giving medium coverage. Medium coverage is not a bad thing, especially if it is buildable. Our take here is that it is a good addition that it lasts a long time.

The lightness of the formula is also a yes for us. This makes it easy to be worn alone when blended, or with powder. It sits well under any other product.

But the fragrance and the package are a no-no for us. The number of users allergic to fragrances or scents in skincare products seems to be on the rise. So, it could be better.

Overall, we think it is good enough to recommend to you, barring any allergies.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Post Comment