Foundation is a personal thing. What works perfectly for you might be a nightmare for another person. Between the Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations, if you want to know which would work excellently on your skin, then stick with us as we bring you this detailed comparison.
In this article, we will shed some light on their shade availability, dispensing technique, wear time, sun protection, and other vital information that will aid you in making an informed decision before rushing to the drugstore counter.
Comparison Overview – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
First of all, the Revlon Colorstay boasts of about 45 shades for combination/oily skin types and 25 for the normal/dry skin types. On the other hand, Maybelline Fit Me is available in a variety of 40 shades.
Second, Maybelline Fit Me is ideal for normal to oily skin types while Revlon Colorstay is ideal for both oily/combination skin and normal/dry skin types.
Third, although they both have sun protection, Maybelline offers SPF 18 while Colorstay offers only 15.
Furthermore, both foundations have a creamy texture and offer medium yet buildable coverage.
Revlon Colorstay offers a matte finish for the oil/combination skin types and demi-matte for normal/dry skin types. Maybelline provides a flawless and poreless matte finish.
Also, Revlon Colorstay and Maybelline Fit Me are both lightweight. So your skin can breathe properly when you wear them.
According to advertised claims, Revlon Colorstay can last for over 24 hours while Maybelline Fit Me can be worn for just 5 to 6 hours.
As for their packaging, both come in rectangular glass bottles. But Revlon Colorstay has a dispensing pump while Maybelline Fit Me does not have any.
Furthermore, the Revlon Colorstay and Maybelline Fit Me are both allergy-tested. So rest assured your skin won’t react or get irritated by them. However, they get easily oxidized when exposed to air.
Lastly, they both have a quantity of one fluid ounce. Even though they have considerably good moisturizing effect, they do not contain oil or phthalates.
Price/Value Ratio – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Which of the foundations offers more value for money?
Revlon Colorstay foundation offers more value for money.
First, it offers more SPF value of 18, comapred to Maybelline Fit Me SPF value of 15. Second, it contains no parabens whereas Maybelline Fit Me contains parabens.
Additionally, it lasts longer than Maybelline, a whopping 24 hours in all. And it has more number of shades available than Maybelline Fit Me.
Comparison Table – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Maybelline Fit Me
|Shades||45 and 25||40|
|Finish||Matte and semi-matte||Matte|
|Packaging and Dispensing Technique||Transparent glass bottle with a pump||See-through glass bottle without a pump|
|Coverage||Medium yet buildable||Moderate yet buildable|
|Staying Power||24 hours||5 to 6 hours|
|Skin Suitability||oily/combination and normal/dry skin||Normal to oily skin|
|Revlon ColorStay Makeup for Combination/Oily Skin SPF 15, Longwear Liquid Foundation, with Medium-Full Coverage, Matte Finish, Oil Free, 150 Buff, 1.0 oz||PrimeEligible||Buy Now|
|Maybelline Fit Me Matte + Poreless Liquid Foundation Makeup, Fair Porcelain, 1 fl. oz. Oil-Free Foundation||PrimeEligible||Buy Now|
Product prices and availability are accurate as of the date/time indicated and are subject to change. Any price and availability information displayed on [relevant Amazon Site(s), as applicable] at the time of purchase will apply to the purchase of this product.Prices pulled from the Amazon Product Advertising API on:
Which Is Better under What Circumstance? – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Maybelline Fit Me
|Firstly, Revlon Colorstay is better for combination/oily skin and normal/dry skin types.
There are more shades available for this foundation. So if you have had trouble getting the right shade with other foundations, try this.
Additionally, the best result is obtained when applied during the day because it does not shimmer.
Also, if you are very concerned about wastage, the pump of the Colorstay makes it very easy to dispense. So globs of the product are not wasted any time you use it.
Finally, if you are on the lookout for parabens, then this product is for you. It does not contain any trace of parabens.
|On the other hand, this product is ideal for normal to oily skin. It is equally great for extremely dry and sensitive skin because it does not cause allergic reactions.
If you are easily irritated by scented makeups and want a foundation that is fragrance-free, then try this.
In fact, it is common knowledge that there are not many foundations that cater for olive skin tones. This makeup has a soft tan shade that matches perfectly with that skin tone.
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
L’Oreal Lash Paradise Mystic Black vs Blackest Black – Comprehensive Comparison
Revlon Gel Envy vs Sally Hansen Gel Nail Polishes — In-depth Comparison
Olay Regenerist Micro-Sculpting Face Cream vs Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Face Cream – Which Is Better?
Clinique Moisture Surge Extended Thirst Relief vs Intense Hydrator – Detailed Comparison
Maybelline Fit Me Concealer Light vs Fair – Which Do You Prefer?
Clinique 7-Day Scrub vs Exfoliating Scrub – Extensive Comparison
Video: Wear Test and Review of the Revlon Colorstay Foundation
If you want to have an idea about the lasting power, skin suitability and other vital information about Revlon Colorstay Foundation, watch this video…
Common Features – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
The following are the features both foundations have in common:
- Broad spectrum sunscreen
- Oil content
- Fluid content
- Non-comedogenic properties
- No phthalates
Broad Spectrum Sunscreen Protection
Which of the foundations offers more sun protection value?
Revlon Colorstay foundation offers more sunprotection value at 18, while Maybelline stays at 15.
However, these foundations are both formulated with titanium dioxide to offer sun protection.
Nowadays, many makeup companies add sunscreen protective ingredients in their products to serve as palliative measures against sunburns. However, if you are extremely susceptible to sunburns, we advise you not to settle for these foundations alone. To learn more about sunscreen, check out this article.
Both foundations are 100 percent oil-free. So if you have oily zones or breakouts caused by excess oil consider going for any of them. They contain salicylic acid which helps to control oil in the skin.
Meanwhile, we must quickly mention that for those with dry skin, oil moisturizers should be used in reasonable amounts. This article here explains more about moisturizers.
Furthermore, even though oil has its place in makeup products, the best type of makeup to use is the oil-free type.
Also, the Revlon Colorstay and Maybelline Fit Me weigh only a fluid ounce. However, this is not a rip off considering their prices.
They both offer medium to buildable coverage.
To begin with, these foundations do not clog the pores of your skin due to the absence of comedogenic ingredients such as stearic acid, A&D additives, flaxseed oil and mink oil. Hence, the probability of breakouts erupting is very unlikely.
However, we must point out that because there are no regulations in place to check for these ingredients in cosmetics, makeup producers maintain that their products promote clear skin. But in reality, most of these cosmetics contain pore-clogging ingredients. So you must have an eagle eye for these ingredients when purchasing any makeup.
Phthalates are chemicals used in the coating of drugs, household wares, cosmetics and nutritional supplements. Studies have shown that high amounts of these substances could cause birth defects.
In light of the above, governments have established policies and stringent regulations to force manufacturers to use phthalate-free ingredients in production. Hence, rest assured that both Revlon Colorstay and Maybelline do not contain such ingredients.
Just like most drugstore foundations, these products oxidize a great deal. When they come in contact with air, the shades tend to have a dark coloration.
Hence, it is advised you give allowance for oxidation by opting for a shade lighter than your original one.
Both foundations are considered to be hypoallergenic. This means they do not cause allergic reactions or irritation. They also work great on extremely dry skin.
Additionally, Revlon Colorstay and Maybelline Fit Me both have a creamy texture. They are richly pigmented and so you need to just apply them sparingly to get the job done.
Properties Unique to Each – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
The following are the features each product has uniquely:
- Staying power
- Skin suitability
- Packaging and dispensing technique
- Available shades
Which of the foundations lasts longer?
Revlon Colorstay lasts longer than Maybelline Fit Me. It boasts of over 24 hours lasting power. Even though people hardly wear makeup that long, it will take you all day if the need arises. On the other hand, Maybelline Fit Me can be worn for about 6 hours without smudging.
What skin type is each foundation suitable for?
Revlon Colorstay foundation is suitable for normal/dry skin type and oily combination skin type. So it is available in two formulations: oily/combination skin and normal/dry skin. Maybelline Fit Me works perfectly on normal to oily skin.
Packaging and Dispensing Technique
What type of packaging and dispensing technique does each foundation have?
Both foundations come in transparent glass bottles. Their glass bottles make them not exactly travel-friendly.
However, Revlon Colorstay has a dispensing pump for easy and hygienic dispensing of the liquid content. But you have to uncap Maybelline Fit Me foundation and pour out the liquid content.
Which of the foundations has no fragrance?
Maybelline Fit Me is completely fragrance-free. This is a great feature because some fragrances can lead to irritation and allergies. On the other hand, Revlon Colorstay has a somewhat pungent fragrance which some persons find to be off-putting.
What is the consistency of each foundation?
Revlon Colorstay and Maybelline Fit Me foundations both have a thick consistency. However, Revlon Colorstay is slightly thicker than Maybelline Fit Me.
Which of the foundations contains parabens?
Maybelline Fit Me contains parabens in the form of methylparaben. Revlon Colorstay does not contain any form of parabens.
Parabens are substances that help to extend the shelf life of cosmetics for months or even years. This is achieved by preventing the increase of bacteria within the product.
However, if they find their way into the body through the skin, they can disrupt hormonal functions of the body and cause birth defects.
How many available shades does each foundation have?
Revlon Colorstay has over 45 shades for the combination/oily skin and 25 for the normal/dry skin types. On the other hand, Maybelline Fit Me has 40 shades available in the market.
What is the finish of each foundation?
Revlon Colorstay offers a matte finish for the oil/combination skin type and demi-matte for normal/dry skin types.
On the other hand, Maybelline Fit Me is formulated with blurring micro-powder that absorbs oil and gives a flawless and poreless-looking matte finish.
Unique Pros – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Pros Unique to the Revlon Colorstay
i. Higher sunscreen protection.
ii. Also, longer staying power.
iii. Suitable for oily/combination and dry/normal skin types.
iv. More shades available.
v. Lastly, pump dispensing technique.
Pros Unique to the Maybelline Fit Me
i. Gives a matte and poreless finish.
ii. Also, it is free of fragrance.
Video: A Look at the Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundation
Watch this review and demo to know if the Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundation is really worth the hype…
Check out these other interesting comparison articles:
Olay Total Effects 7-in-1 Moisturizer vs L’Oréal Revitalift Triple Power Intensive Moisturizer – Detailed Comparison
Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations – Which to Go for?
Clinique Moisture Surge Intense Hydrator vs Dramatically Different Moisturizing Gel – Extensive Comparison
Maybelline New York Fit Me Matte + Poreless vs Dewy + Smooth Foundations Classic Ivory – Which Should You Go for?
Maybelline Baby Skin Instant Pore Eraser vs Benefit Porefessional Primers – Extensive Comparison
Unique Cons – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Cons Unique to the Revlon Colorstay
i. Kind of thick.
ii. Also, it has a weird fragrance.
Cons Unique to the Maybelline Fit Me
i. Shorter staying power.
ii. Lesser shades available.
iii. Lower sun protection.
iv. Also, no dispensing medium.
v. Contains parabens.
Common Pros – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Maybelline Fit Me
|Oil-free||It is completely void of oil or pore-clogging ingredients.||Similarly, this product is totally oil-free.|
|Sun protection||The Colorstay is formulated with Titanium Dioxide to protects the skin from sunburn.||Likewise, this option contains sun protection ingredients.|
|Allergy-tested||Also, it does not cause allergic reactions.||In like manner, this option is considered to be hypoallergenic.|
|Affordable||You get value for every cent spent on this product.||Similarly, this product is also very affordable.|
|Coverage||It effectively covers every spot and blemishes on the face and neck.||In like manner, Maybelline Fit Me has good coverage.|
|Texture and pigmentation||Also, the Revlon Colorstay is richly pigmented and has a creamy texture.||Similarly, Maybelline Fit Me is richly pigmented and cream in texture.|
Common Cons – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Maybelline Fit Me
|Oxidation||This product tends to oxidize a lot.||In like manner, Maybelline Fit Me oxidizes a great deal.|
|Poor packaging||Also, it comes in a rectangular glass bottle which may easily get broken if not handled with care.||Similarly, this option is poorly packaged.|
|Fluid Content||The content of the Revlon Colorstay is only one fluid ounce. And so, it will get used up quickly.||Likewise, this product will run out very quickly due to its small content.|
What Users Feel about Them – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Maybelline Fit Me
|Many users like its wearing time. In fact, some users said it stayed put from morning till night without the need for a touch-up.
Even though it has a thick consistency, the reviews show it is not heavy on the face.
Also, the pump-assisted dispensing medium was appreciated and considered by many as a big relief.
However, the oxidation rate and presence of parabens turned off many customers.
|On the other hand, users with sensitive skin were elated by its suitability on their skin.
Also, many customers considered it as a worthy alternative to other expensive foundations. The quality makes it worth every penny it goes for.
However, the packaging and oxidation rate were off-putting to many customers.
Our Verdict – Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations
Maybelline Fit Me
|To begin with, we like that it works great on four skin types. If you fall into the combination/oily or normal/dry skin category, then Revlon Colorstay has got you covered.
Also, a total of over 70 shades gives you the liberty of choosing the best match for you.
Its 24 hours staying power is a sterling feat we noticed in this product.
Lastly, the weird fragrance is a let-down for us.
|On the other hand, we consider it as a worthy dupe for other high-end foundations.
Also, we do not take for granted that it does not contain parabens or any other harmful substances.
It is a huge win for us to have a fragrance free makeup.
The price of the Maybelline Fit Me makes it even more attractive.
However, the glass bottle packaging is a no-no for us. Plus, it contains parabens.
Revlon Colorstay vs Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundations – Frequently Asked Questions
Is Maybelline Fit Me Foundation Good for Oily Skin?
Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless foundation is good for oily skin. In fact, it is perfect for normal to oily skin. This is because it is specifically formulated to suit the oily nature of oily skin. it tends to dry up excess oil and curb the appearance of shine on the face.
Therefore, it keeps oily face less shiny and makes reduces the appearance of pores. Since oily skin tends to have large and visible pores, this foundation gives the face a poreless look.
Does Maybelline Fit Me Clog Pores?
Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless foundation does not clog pores. because it is made specially to suit oily skin, it is completely free of oil. This means it does not add grease to the skin, increase oil on the skin or leave any residue that is capable of clogging the pores.
Additionally, it has non-comedogenic properties. That is, the foundation does not contain ingredients that are known to clog pores. This further reduces the chances of the foundation to clog pores.
Is Revlon Colorstay Foundation Full Coverage?
Revlon Colorstay foundation is full coverage. What this means is that the foundation offers medium coverage that you can build up to full coverage.
So if you are one to wear light makeup, you can use one layer of the foundation. But you favor full makeup or have really dark blemishes to hide, this foundation will still serve you well.
Its thick consistency makes its full coverage possible. What’s more, one application of this foundation will take for 24 hours. Given, nobody wears makeup that long. But it means you don’t need to reapply it all through the day unless you want to.
How Do You Apply Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless Foundation?
To properly apply Maybelline Fit Me Matte and Poreless foundation for the best results:
- Wash or cleanse your face.
- Moisturize it with a good and lasting moisturizer. This is to keep your skin hydrated under all the makeup.
- Apply your primer. It will help keep the foundation and other makeup products in place all day.
- Then apply the foundation, starting with a light coating and building it until you achieve the level of coverage you desire. Never begin with a thick coating.
After this, use any other makeup product you want. But be sure to allow the foundation to dry first.
Is Revlon Colorstay Foundation Good for Acne-prone Skin?
Revlon Colorstay foundation is good for acne-prone skin. The oily/combination type fits acne-prone skin as it does not contain any oil. It is lightweight and works at keeping oily skin free of any shine, even in the heat of the day.
The foundation dries up excess oil with its matte finish and does not settle into pores or lines. this means that it leaves the skin able to breathe, eliminating the chances of dirt and oil mixing to create room for acne-causing bacteria. Moreover, it is non-comedogenic, meaning it does not clog pores.
Is Revlon Colorstay Foundation Oil or Water-based?
Revlon Colorstay foundation is neither oil-based nor water-based. Rather, it is silicone-based. However, it will have some water in it so that its viscosity is reduced. Therefore, it is easy to say it is water-based. This is especially true for the oily/combination skin type as it contains no oil.
However, it is still perfect for oily skin type. The base does not detract from its effectiveness. In fact, it makes it very effective. Besides, you do not have to worry about the foundation being too light for you. This is part of the reason it is a favorite with many users.