Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3 – Which Should You Buy?

Clinique Clarifying Lotion #2, 200ml, 6.7oz Clinique Clarifying Lotion Twice a Day Exfoliator #3, 6.7oz, 200ml

This is an extensive comparison of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3. Read through if you want to get detailed information on these two lotions. But for a quick run-through on which product to buy, check out the overview, comparison table, and which is better under what circumstance? sections.


Table of Contents

Comparison Overview- Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

The main purpose of this article is to highlight the beauty and importance of these lotions. Secondly, to also give their differences and similarities. This will help you make an informed decision on which you should buy.

The advantages each product has over the other are clearly stated. Their content, uniqueness and peculiarities are also included.

The main differences lie in their ingredients, the most suitable skin type for each product, and their effect on the skin.

Both products are great exfoliants. They give your skin the soothing pamper it deserves.

Clinique Clarifying Lotion #2, 200ml, 6.7oz Clinique Clarifying Lotion Twice a Day Exfoliator #3, 6.7oz, 200ml




Price/Value Ratio – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

Which of the lotions offers more value for money?

Clinique Lotion 3 offers more value for money than the Clinique Lotion 2. The reason for this is that Lotion 3 is more moisturizing for the skin. It also protects the skin from external pollutants better than the Lotion 2.

Additionally, Lotion 3 has a wider range of ingredients that make the skin smoother and better than Lotion 2.


Comparison Table – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3


Lotion 2

Lotion 3

Product Dimensions 1.8 x 1.8 x 6.8 inches 1.5 x 1.8 x 6.8 inches
Shipping Weight 9.6 ounces 9.6 ounces
Fragrance None None
Oil content No oil Zero oil
Clinique Clarifying Lotion #2, 200ml, 6.7oz Clinique Clarifying Lotion Twice a Day Exfoliator #3, 6.7oz, 200ml



Which Is Better under What Circumstance? – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

If you have the dry combination skin type, you need the Lotion 2. Because it is made specifically for your skin type. Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3 is for the combination oily skin type.

For the Asians, combination oily is the product to go for. There is a special consideration for your skin type during the formulation process.

During winter, the skin is usually hydrated, so the use of the dry combination lotion might not be necessary. However, in summer, Lotion 2 is the perfect face exfoliant.

For easily irritable skin, Lotion 3 is most suitable. It is milder on the skin.

However, it is most important to know your skin type. So you don’t buy a product that isn’t suitable for you. It will do very little good for your skin.


Video: A Review of Lotion 2

Watch this video to see how well the Lotion sits on the skin…



Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

MAC Fluidline Eyeliner Gel vs Maybelline Eyestudio Gel Eyeliner – Extensive Comparison

Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions – Thorough Comparison

Nars Radiant Creamy vs Maybelline Fit Me Concealers – Detailed Comparison

Maybelline Dream Lumi Touch Highlighting Concealers Radiant vs Ivory – Extensive Comparison

Milani Color Statement Black Cherry vs Revlon Super Lustrous Black Cherry Lipsticks – Honest Comparison

MAC Paint Pot Bare Study vs Maybelline Eyestudio Color Tattoo Metal Barely Branded – Extensive Comparison




Common Features – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

The following are the common features both lotions have:

  • Oil content
  • Efficacy
  • Fragrance
  • Anti-allergen
  • Paraben-free
  • Absorption rate
  • Silicone and sulfate-free
  • Ingredients


Let us take a look at each feature in details.


Oil Content

These products are both oil-free exfoliants. Also, they are non-greasy, alcohol-based face lotions. That’s why the face is usually squeaky clean and fresh after use.



True to their reputation, these Clarifying Lotions are great at skin exfoliation. They rid the skin of acne and cleans, clears, moisturizes and smoothens the face. Furthermore, they unblock clogged pores.

Another awesome fact about these products is that they accommodate almost every skin type. So if you have a dry, flaky or chafed skin, Clinique has got you covered. What about the oily combination skin type? There is something for you, too.



Both Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 and 3 are fragrance-free face exfoliants. Now, fragrance-free does not mean they lack scent. Other ingredients in the formulation have their individual scents. Together, they may form a unique scent for the product. But there is no added fragrance in the products.



Thankfully, these products have a tendency to prevent skin allergies. Many users have attested to this fact. In addition to this, they control allergic symptoms and restore affected areas.



Parabens are widely known as preservatives. They are often used to enhance and improve the service life of products. They are believed to cause hormonal dysfunctions and increased probability of breast cancer. Also, reproductive issues are more likely to crop up with parabens.

However, parabens are totally absent from these lotions. So the health issues that crop up with parabens are not likely to happen because of using these products.


Absorption Rate

The presence of butylene glycol, alcohol denat and glycerin, which are common ingredients in the formulation of these products, causes seamless and easy absorption. These products work by opening and unclogging the pores. As a result, the products seep deep and quick into the skin.


Silicone and Sulfate-free

Silicones are water-resistant. They have no business with beauty and skincare products. You encounter great difficulty trying to wipe them off the face and they block the pores.

As a result, dirt gets trapped in the skin. Also, their waterproof nature stops other ingredients as well as moisture from absorbing into the skin. This results in dehydration, which in turn causes dry, flaky or chafed skin.

Sulfates are also a no-no. They worsen skin problems like rosacea, acne and eczema.  Always look out for your skin, by looking out for, and avoiding these ingredients in your skincare products.



The common active ingredients in the lotions are:


Salicylic acid

It is used in various anti-acne products. Mostly known for its use in cosmetic products, this ingredient is used mainly for curing skin issues like warts.

To do this, it increases the amount of moisture in the skin. As a result, the substances that cause stickiness on the skin cells are destroyed. That way, warts are removed, and dead cells don’t remain on the skin surface. This is why it is a great exfoliant used in the production of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 and 3.


Sodium hyaluronate

This ingredient helps reduce wrinkles on the face. It also allows easier entry of products into the skin. It is therefore popular among skin and beauty care products.

With its enhanced ability to enter the skin and retain water, it is a sought- for in beauty and skincare products. The good news is, it is a major and active ingredient in the formulation of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 and 3.


Citric acid

This ingredient is inherent in fruits like oranges and lemons. You know the effects of fruits on human skin cannot be overemphasized. It is a very potent ingredient for treating skin problems like acne and dark spots. In the world of cosmetics, it is used as a skin toner.

Also, it deals with problems of inconsistent skin tones. Additionally, it helps in opening up blocked skin pores and curing wrinkles. Thankfully, it is an active ingredient in these products.



When used in cosmetic products, glycerin prevents persistent and awful dryness. This is because of its moisturizing properties. That’s why you should opt for products with glycerin.

Glycerin also has the ability to attract water to itself. Being a moisturizer, it attracts more moisture and keeps the skin hydrated at all times.


Butylene glycol

This ingredient is infused in beauty care products to enhance the absorption of the entire formula. Many beauty products today are not potent. This, however, is because the constituents of the formula do not absorb well into the skin. They just sit on the skin surface doing little or no good for the skin.

Butylene glycol also boosts the total potency of products. Being a solvent, it helps other ingredients to mix. Most noteworthy is its ability to draw moisture to itself from the airspace. Skin hydration is not left out. In addition, it slows down the emergence of wrinkles.


Hamamelis virginiana (witch hazel)

It is also of plant origin with strong healing abilities. Other species of witch hazel exists, but Hamamelis virginiana is the most common species. It is indigenous to North America and can be made into lotions.

Witch hazel is prominent for its use on body surfaces and sometimes scalp. Most importantly, it has been known for its ability to relieve swellings. It also calms sensitive skin. Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 and 3 has this ingredient. Yeah, I said so.


Alcohol denat.

It is widely known as denatured alcohol. Alcohol denat. is just an abbreviation. However, as the name implies, it is ethanol, the most commonly used alcohol. Also, it is sometimes referred to as ethyl alcohol.

Denatured alcohol is popularly known as an astringent, a material which causes skin tissues to shrink. Additionally, it is used in cosmetic products as a substance that allows quick-drying, and disallows stickiness on the skin. Furthermore, it removes grease, acne and leaves the skin feeling light and fluffy.



It is a solvent used universally in the formulation of almost every kind of cosmetic and beauty care product. This very important solvent primarily dissolves ingredients that relay to the skin. In addition, it is an effective moisturizer.

However, only toxin-free, pollutant-free and microbe-free water is used in the making of beauty products. It could interchangeably be called aqua, refined or uncontaminated water.

Clinique Clarifying Lotion #2, 200ml, 6.7oz Clinique Clarifying Lotion Twice a Day Exfoliator #3, 6.7oz, 200ml




Unique Features – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

The unique features of the products are:

  • Colorant
  • Trehalose


What are these features? Let us take a look at each of them.



Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 has the red 33. This ingredient is an artificial and benign colorant utilized in making different beauty products. The beautiful colour of the Lotion 2 is courtesy of this ingredient.

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3 has the orange 4 as a unique ingredient. So this product has a unique colour because of it.



There is also Trehalose in Lotion 3. It acts as a skin moisturizer and also shields the skin from environmental pollutants.



Unique Pros – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3


Unique Pros of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2


Which of the Lotions Comes in a Bigger Package: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 comes in a bigger package than the Lotion 3. This equally means that its liquid content is more than that of Lotion 3.


Which of the Lotions Suits Dry Skin Better: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Lotion 2 suits dry skin better than Lotion 3. In fact, it fits the dry combination skin type best. However, other skin types can use it.


Which of the Lotions Rids the Skin of Acne Better: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Lotion 2 rids the skin of acne better than Lotion 3. It also makes the skin glow and improves its texture.


Unique Pros of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3 


Which of the Lotions is More Travel-friendly: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Lotion 3 is more travel friendly. The reason is that it comes in a smaller package than Lotion 2. This makes it easy to fit into any travel case.


Which of the Lotions Contains More Ingredients: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Lotion 3 contains more ingredients than Lotion 2. Due to this, it is more moisturizing and soothing. It is also great for Asian skin type.


Which of the Lotions Fits the Oily Combination Skin Type Better: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Lotion 3 suits the oily combination skin type better, one of the most difficult skin types to please. However, it is also suitable for other skin types.


Which of the Lotions Reduces Oil Secretion Better: Lotion 2 or Lotion 3?

Clinique Lotion 3 reduces the secretion of oil in the skin better. This is why it is made for oily combination skin type. Enlarged pores are reduced to curb the amount of oil coming to the surface of the skin.


Unique Cons – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

As a rule, most things with advantages have corresponding disadvantages. About these two products, there are things you might not like. Take a look.


Unique Cons of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2



This product causes a tingling, almost stinging effect. This may be as a result of the presence of more alcohol content than the Lotion 3. This also causes it to give a drying effect to the skin.



This product, being an alcohol-based face exfoliant, has a strong, almost choking alcoholic smell. It fades almost immediately but could cause nose irritation if used carelessly.


Unique Cons of Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3



Despite the special consideration given to this product during formulation, it still irritates the skin. For some very delicate and sensitive skin types, it can cause an acetone splash effect on the face. The resultant effect is burns and irritations.



This product is smaller in dimension than the Lotion 2. It has, therefore, been considered inferior to the former. As a result, there is less demand and less positive reviews.


Common Pros – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

Lotion 2

Lotion 3

Even Out Skin Based on popular reviews, this product evens out the skin, shrinks the appearance of pores, and improves complexion. The same is applicable to Lotion 3.
Anti-aging Properties Sodium hyaluronate alongside other active ingredients in this product causes anti-aging effects on the skin. It consequently results in a fresher, younger look. Lotion 3 also has sodium hyaluronate as an active ingredient. This product has anti-aging effects on the skin, with the result being a radiant, beautiful and younger-looking skin.
Great Exfoliants Clinique clarifying Lotion 2 does a great job at exfoliating the skin. It removes layers of dirt, worn out or dead cells. This leaves the face fresh, weightless and beautiful. Lotion 3, on the other hand, is an amazing face exfoliant. It is great at removing layers of dead cells. You know the rest, a cleaner, fresher and weightless skin.
Excellent Moisturizers It is not only good at exfoliation but also an excellent moisturizer. It softens, moisturizes, clear and smoothens the skin. Glycerine is one active ingredient that causes that moisturizing effect. Glycerin is an active ingredient in the Lotion 3. This product also moisturizes, soften and smoothens the skin, leaving it clean and beautiful.
Clinique Clarifying Lotion #2, 200ml, 6.7oz Clinique Clarifying Lotion Twice a Day Exfoliator #3, 6.7oz, 200ml


Check out these interesting skincare product reviews/articles:

How to Prevent Loose Skin after Gastric Bypass – In-depth Answer

How to Get Smooth Armpit Skin – Detailed Answer

Which Surgical Procedure Removes Superficial Skin Lesions with Scraping?

Neutrogena Men Skin Clearing Acne Wash – Comprehensive Review

What Can Cause Itchy Skin without a Rash? – In-depth Answer

How to Get Rid of Stretched Skin after Pregnancy – Extensive Answer



Common Cons – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

Lotion 2

Lotion 3

Poor Packaging This Lotion has sloppy packaging. The bottle is too wide-mouthed. It spills the product more often than not whenever it is being tilted to a cotton pad. Therefore, spray dispensers will be more appropriate. Similarly, this product also has the same sloppy packaging as lotion 2. It needs a spray dispenser, for easier use, and reduction of spillage.
Strong Smell Being an alcohol-based face exfoliant, it has a strong, almost choking alcoholic smell. Could also irritate the nose. Likewise, this product is an alcohol-based face exfoliant. Also, it has a strong alcoholic smell.
Drying Effect


Alcohol, being a strong astringent, causes skin dryness. The product has high alcohol content. As a result, skin dryness occurs in the long run, with continuous use. Not left out, Clarifying Lotion 3 also causes the drying effect. This is, however, to a lesser degree than the Lotion 2. Alcohol is an active ingredient that causes this effect, being a strong astringent.
Expensive This product is quite expensive. As a result, there have been lots of complaints. Especially since the size is not commensurate with the price. Lotion 3 is also as expensive as Lotion 2. The size, on the other hand, is a major markdown. It is not commensurate with the price it is being sold for.


What People Think about Both Products – Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

Lotion 2

 Lotion 3

Users like the anti-acne properties of this product. They also like that it helps keep complexion even, cleans and moisturizes the skin.

This product is non-greasy and does wonders to the face.

People think this product is great. They like that it hydrates and exfoliates the skin. As a result, the skin is squeaky clean and fresh. Furthermore, it helps with breakouts.
A lot of people think this product is too expensive. In other words, they are not getting value for their money.

The smell of alcohol in this product is too strong for some users.

However, it is a strong astringent that causes dryness so some users didn’t like it.

The size of this product has been a major concern to customers. They think the product is too small, compared to the price it is being sold for. Hence, a few decided to opt for cheaper products that does a similar job.

Clinique Clarifying Lotion #2, 200ml, 6.7oz Clinique Clarifying Lotion Twice a Day Exfoliator #3, 6.7oz, 200ml




Our Take on Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3

We believe Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3 is better than Lotion 2 because of its moisturizing properties and its skin suitability.

There is also the fact it protects the skin better from external pollutants than Lotion 2.


Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3 – Frequently Asked Questions


What Is the Difference between Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 and 3?

The difference between Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 and Lotion 3 is mainly in the skin type each is suitable for. While Lotion 2 is suitable for the dry combination skin type, Lotion 3 is suitable for the oily combination skin type.

There is also a difference in the number of ingredients. Lotion 3 has more ingredients than Lotion 2. It contains Trehalose, which is great at moisturizing. But Lotion 2 does not contain this ingredient.

Additionally, there are differences in size and colorants. Lotion 2 is bigger than Lotion 3 and Lotion 2 contains red 33 while Lotion contains orange 4.


Is Clinique Clarifying Lotion A Toner?

Clinique Clarifying Lotion is not a toner. Neither Lotion 2 nor Lotion 3 is a toner but exfoliating lotions. Toners act like astringents but are more refined. But these lotions exfoliate the skin and also moisturize at the same time.

The two lotions work at clearing the skin to make for better-looking and smoother skin. When the skin is properly exfoliated, it makes way for other skincare products to work faster and better. And with these, you don’t have to use extra moisturizer. They moisturize while exfoliating.


What Is Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3 Used for?

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 3 is used to moisturize and exfoliate the skin. Because it is good for oily skin, it is used to control oil production in the skin and curb its flow to the surface. This reduces the shine on the face.

This oil control curbs the appearance of pimples and acne. The lotion also unclogs stuffed pores on the face, thereby reducing the chances of having a breakout.

Overall, Lotion 3 is used to get squeaky-clean, well hydrated and healthier skin.


Does Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 Have Salicylic Acid?

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 does not have salicylic acid. In fact, all the other products in the Clarifying Lotion line has salicylic acid except Clarifying Lotion 2.

Salicylic acid is a beta hydroxy acid which is soluble in oil. This is comparable to alpha-hydroxy acids that are soluble in water. Salicylic acid, therefore, is great at sinking through the skin without being obstructed by the natural oils of the skin.

It is known to dissolve keratin, a protein that holds dead skin cells in place and it is also good at unclogging pores.


What Is the Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 for?

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 is used to clean dirt, remove accumulated dead skin and clean pollution. The result is much clearer, cleaner, smoother and generally healthier skin.

With the lotion, there is no obstruction in the skin against the entrance of other skincare products to work maximally. If anything, it clears the way for them to enter by making absorption easier.

Additionally, it helps the skin retain moisture to keep it hydrated. This will even help the lines that come from lack of moisture to vanish.


Do You Rinse Off Clinique Clarifying Lotion?

You do not rinse off Clinique Clarifying Lotion, whichever one you choose to use. There are Clinique Clarifying Lotion 1,2,3 and 4 and each is suitable for different skin types.

But before you apply any of the lotions that is suitable for you, you have to wash your face with a mild face wash or soap. This step will make the lotion more effective than wif you did not wash your face. It is the face wash or soap that you must rinse off thoroughly before applying the lotion.