Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions – Thorough Comparison

 

Who rejects well defined eyelashes? The only challenge is getting them, as many of us have less-than-perfect lashes. Use falsies then. Uhm, you probably feel they need much dedication and may weigh down or pull off your natural lashes. Now that brings mascara into the ring. So we are comparing Covergirl Clump Crusher Vs Clump Crusher extensions to oust any confusion.

Mascara may be used to create darker, thicker, more defined and lengthy eyelashes. Usually, they come in liquid form. However, a few may be powdery or creamy. Whichever form they come in, they have basic ingredients in common. Usually, they contain pigments, oils, waxes, and preservatives.

One major reason why we all love mascara is that they’re easy to apply and remove. Also, they have conditioners that show more mercy to lashes than falsies do.

Notwithstanding, they can cause allergies and you could scratch your cornea with the applicator.

 

Comparison Overview — Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

It can get confusing when a brand opts for different versions of a particular product. For Covergirl especially, it seems they live and breathe mascara.

Clump Crusher stands as the older form of Clump Crusher Extensions. But then, being of the same brand, is there any difference at all?

Well, the finish is the difference and the difference is the finish. Therefore, while the Extension mascara gives more length, the Clump Crusher serves more volume. The Extension also has a drier formula.

However, they have many similarities. The packaging is near exact — the same formula, and even the same applicator. Also, both come in shades of very dark, dark, black-brown and brown. And there is a water-resistant formula available.

It’s interesting to note that both indeed crush clumps and separate the lashes beautifully. Moreover, they offer no flakes and also add buildable volume to your natural lashes. To cap the product quality, they last long and can be cleaned easily as well.

A major magic, though, lies in the curved applicator. It has a short handle with curved bristled ends. These bristles or brushes, though stiff, are short and evenly spaced. For clarity, we advise against confusion when you get any of these products. This is because the features written on both are perfectly the same but worded differently.

 

Price/Value Ratio – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

Which of the mascaras gives more value for money?

The Clump Crusher Extensions mascara gives more value for money than the Clump Crusher. This is because it succeeds in separating lashes better and dries quicker than the other option. Plus it makes the lashes appear longer than they actually are.

Nonetheless, the Clump Crusher adds more volume, thus making the lashes look fuller than they actually are.

For the price they go for, these are valuable benefits.

 

Comparison Table – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

	Clump Crusher Mascara	Clump Crusher Extension
Shades	4	4
Packaging	Bright green bottle with a wand applicator	Bright green bottle with a wand applicator
Staying power	Long	Long
Formula	Fiber stretch	Fiber stretch
Finish	Less separated lashes	More separated lashes
Clumping	No clumps	No clumps
Volume	More  volume	Less volume
Length	Less length

 

 

Which Is Better for What Situation? – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

Clump Crusher Mascara	Clump Crusher Extension
It is established that this product eliminates clumps indeed, but it doesn’t end there. Additionally, this product is a tad wetter than the Extension. Also, it delivers a much fuller appearance, courtesy of its less dry feature. Therefore, if you prefer fuller/wetter lashes to fluttery but less voluminous lashes, then this will do.	The Extension mascara gives more separated lashes. It is also drier than the other, no wonder the fluttery finish. However, the volume it gives seems less than that of the Clump Crusher. So, if you prefer fluttery to volume, then you may have to check this out.

Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara on Amazon	Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara on Amazon

 

 

 

Common Features – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

The following are the features which both mascaras have in common:

• Formula
• Staying power
• Consistency
• Packaging
• Volume
• Length

 

The details of each feature are discussed below.

 

Formula

A great advantage for both mascaras is their fiber stretch formula. Why? It ensures that they can hold up lashes without smudging. Also, it ensures that both products give the sense of having longer and ample lashes.

 

Staying Power

Clump Crusher and the Extension mascara do have a decent staying power. As a result, smudges may only appear after about 6 hours of wear.

But then, this may not hold for everyone depending on the skin type and the weather condition. However, compared to the average mascara, they do have good staying power.

 

Consistency

Being in a liquid state, both are neither too thick nor thin. Rather, they’re light enough to be worn with comfort even after more than the suggested three coats.

 

Packaging

Both mascaras come in an identical lemon green bottle with a wand applicator. But you’ll have to discard the original cover and replace it with the wand.

Also, the wand has a curved end with short bristles that are evenly spaced. The curved end and the tiny spaces between the bristle help the wand to hug the lashes properly. That way, it prevents clumping as you apply the mascara.

Finally, it ensures that only a little of the product comes out on the wand. Therefore, you can’t convey excess products to your lashes. More so, the curved edge helps to reach the whole curvature of the eye. This goes from the base of the lashes to the tip of them.

 

Volume

They add decent volume to the lashes but the Clump Crusher seems to do a better job of that. However, their added volumes do not seem to be dramatic enough in comparison to certain volumizing mascaras.

 

Length

Actually, both products indeed lengthen the eyelashes or seem to create that sense of being longer. But then, the Extension mascara does a better job of this than its counterpart. However, both seem to favor a more natural look. Therefore, if you want something theatrical, you may need to layer with more lengthening mascara.

Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara on Amazon	Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara on Amazon

 

Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

Clinique 7-Day Scrub vs Exfoliating Scrub – Extensive Comparison

Clinique Clarifying Lotion 2 vs 3 — Which Should You Buy?

Olay Total Effects 7-in-1 Moisturizer vs L’Oréal Revitalift Triple Power Intensive Moisturizer – Detailed Comparison

Neutrogena SkinClearing Classic Ivory 10 vs Healthy Skin Natural Ivory 20 Foundations – Which to Go for?

Clinique Moisture Surge Intense Hydrator vs Dramatically Different Moisturizing Gel – Extensive Comparison

Nars Radiant Creamy vs Maybelline Fit Me Concealers – Detailed Comparison

 

Video: Differences between Both Products

It can be tempting to view both products as being the same. However, this video will help you see them differently.

Unique Features – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

Which features does each mascara have uniquely?

The Covergirl Clump Crusher has a wetter consistency than the Clump Crusher Extensions. This feature makes the former give the lashes a fuller look than the latter.

The Clump Crusher Extension, on the other hand, does not give much volume to lashes. What it does is to separate lashes better, no matter how close together they are. It also dries faster than the Clump Crusher due to its drier consistency.

Interestingly, these differences are so subtle that depending on the lashes involved, may go unnoticed. Simply put, there aren’t much striking differences between Covergirl Clump Crusher and Extensions.

Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara on Amazon	Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara on Amazon

 

 

Video: So Which Should You Go for?

In this video, you will view the options that can aid your buying choice.

 

 

Unique Pros – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

 

Which of the Mascaras Add More Volume to lashes: Clump Crusher or Clump Crusher Extensions?

The Clump Crusher adds more volume to lashes due to its wet and thick consistency. It is easier to stick to lashes, giving them a fuller lok with its presence.

 

 

Which of the Mascaras Dries Faster: Clump Crusher or Clump Crusher Extensions?

The Clump Crusher Extensions dries faster because of its drier consistency. It is not as wet as the Clump Crusher.

 

Which of the Mascaras Separates the Lashes Better: Clump Crusher or Clump Crusher Extensions?

The Clump Crusher Extensions separates the lashes better. It can do this because it is not as wet as the original Clump Crusher. Therefore, it does not cause the lashes to stick together.

 

Which of the Mascaras Adds More Length: Clump Crusher or Clump Crusher Extensions?

The Clump Crusher Extensions adds more length to lashes than the Clump Crusher. Again, this is attributable to its dry formula, which makes it easier to straighten curled lashes.

 

 

Unique Cons – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

 

Unique Con of Clump Crusher Mascara

i. It doesn’t define and separate the lashes as the Extension mascara does.

 

Unique Con of Clump Crusher Extensions

i. It gives less volume.

 

Common Pros – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

	Clump Crusher Mascara	Clump Crusher Extensions
Zero Clumps	This sounds almost impossible but truly, it gives no clump at all.	Likewise, this holds for the extension mascara.
Buildable Volume	With its fiber stretch formula, you can add more than three strokes to achieve the desired result.	This product achieves a buildable volume as well.
Packaging	Furthermore, it has an eye-catching packaging with a very effective wand. This ensures a less messy application that reaches every part of the lashes, certainly.	This applies to this product too.
Natural Finish	With these products, therefore, you can achieve natural-looking but enhanced eyelashes.	Similarly, this is possible for this product.
Cleaning	Moreover, despite its decent staying power, it is quite easy to wash off at the end of the day.	This product also washes easily even without a makeup remover.
Durability	It also lasts for a long time without running.	This applies to this also.
No Flakes	Finally, it leaves no flakes on the brow line or anywhere around the eyes.	This product leaves no flakes as well.

Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara on Amazon	Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara on Amazon

 

Check out these other interesting comparison articles:

Revlon Colorstay Makeup Foundations 110 Ivory vs 150 Buff – Which Should You Go for?

L’Oréal Paris Infallible Pro-Matte 102 Shell Beige vs Pro-Glow 202 Creamy Natural Foundations – Extensive Comparison

Maybelline Age Rewind Concealer Neutralizer vs Light – Extensive Comparison

L’Oréal Infallible Pro-Matte Foundation 103 vs 104 – Detailed Comparison

Maybelline New York Dream Mousse Foundation Smooth vs Matte – Which Should You Go for?

Neutrogena Rapid Wrinkle Repair Regenerating Cream vs Serum—Detailed Comparison

 

 

Common Cons – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

	Clump Crusher Mascara	Clump Crusher Extensions
Stiff Applicator	Though effective, the bristles seem rather stiff. Therefore, you may be concerned about scratching your cornea on a careless day.	Equally, this product has that exact wand applicator.
May Oxidize	Like a lot of beauty products, this product may get oxidized if unduly exposed. Certainly, the mascara gets solidified and may hurt your eyes.	Likewise, this product runs the same risk.
May Not Hold Curls	Despite all the goodness, it may not hold your curls perfectly.	Also. this applies to this product.

 

What Users Think – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

Clump Crusher Mascara	Clump Crusher Extensions
The majority of the users love the finish this product serves. This is because its ability to define and separate lashes without clumping them together serves as a high point.	Like the other, users gushed about the finish and the anti-clumping ability.
Also, they like the wand applicator because of its effectiveness.	They also praised the applicator despite its stiffness.
Additionally, they praise the durability of the product despite it is easy to remove. To learn more about eye-makeup removers, click here.	Moreover, they appreciated the decent durability it offered.
But on the other hand, the ineptness in lengthening seems to put them off.	Unfortunately, for Extension mascara, they seemed turned off by the volume and length it gave.

 

Bottom Line – Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions

The original Clump Crusher adds volume but causes the lashes to stick together due to its thick and wet consistency. The Clump Crusher Extensions lengthens, straightens and separates lashes better. However, it does not add volume.

These differences will tell you which of them will suit you better.

Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara on Amazon	Buy this Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara on Amazon

 

Covergirl Clump Crusher vs Clump Crusher Extensions – Related Frequently Asked Questions

 

What Does Mascara Do to Your Lashes?

Mascara adds volume to your lashes. The volume makes your lashes appear fuller and thicker. This makes the eyes pop and glimmer, and in some cases, it adds mystery to the eyes.

Mascara also straightens curled lashes. For some people, this stops lashes from getting into the eyes. In addition to that, it separates them so that they don’t remain tangled.

Some mascaras are moisturizing so they make the lashes lush and healthy, keeping them from cutting frequently.

However, there is a chance your lashes will become brittle with mascara. It stiffens lashes and leaves them vulnerable to easy breakage.

 

Is Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara Waterproof?

Covergirl Clump Crusher Mascara is waterproof. The waterproof formula will keep the mascara from running easily, whether you sweat or run underwater. This means your eye makeup remains intact for most of the day.

But be aware that the waterproof quality of any makeup product can only last so long. And it can only take so much wetness before it washes off. Moreover, waterproof mascara will be harder to clean off without using waterproof makeup remover.

It is also important to clean off every bit of it at the end of the day to avoid an accumulation of makeup around the eyes.

 

Is Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara Any Good?

Covergirl Clump Crusher Extensions Mascara is good. In fact, it is an amazing mascara and it is a wonder more people are not talking about it. It is a mascara that works with just one stroke but is still buildable. And despite the fact you can build it, it still leaves your lashes looking all-natural.

Furthermore, it straightens lashes that are curled up and make them appear longer. This gives shade and allure to your eyes. Plus, it is affordable.

If you favor thicker and longer lashes without clumps, the Clump Crusher Extensions is the way to go.

 

Is It Ok to Wear Mascara Every Day?

It is not okay to wear mascara every day. It is true it makes the eyes pop and adds a certain appeal to your makeup and looks. But using it every day will bring some adverse effects to your lashes.

For one, your lashes will be susceptible to dryness. Having to constantly apply and clean such a delicate area will eventually take its toll. Two, you always leave yourself vulnerable to poking your own eyes.

Additionally, there is the chance of developing an eye infection from using unsanitary mascara brushes. They don’t self-clean and since you don’t wash them, they could become contaminated.

 

Do Fake Lashes Ruin Your Real Ones?

It is possible for fake lashes to ruin your real ones, though this is not always the case. If you always fix fake lashes, you will notice that a few of your own lashes come off with the fake ones when it is time to remove them. This is made truer if you yank them off before the adhesive weakens.

Besides, the fake ones do block your real lashes from getting the nutrients they need to flourish. In the long run, you will find your lashes are thin and weak. But you will not have these problems if you don’t always fix fake lashes.

 

Does Wearing Mascara Thin Out Your Lashes?

Wearing mascara thins out your lashes and dries them, too. The lashes, thin and delicate hairs tha they are, can only take so much makeup. Having to constantly apply and clean mascara from the lashes will eventually cause them to start falling out. This will give you thin lashes.

Additionally, if you keep applying mascara, the ingredients will wear out the natural moisture of the lashes, leading to dryness. This is especially true if you don’t care for your eyes properly.